Live data from Hacker News

My main Android phone is now 99% Google free

simondalvai.org

41–43 of 43 posts

Re: My main Android phone is now 99% Google free

#41
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are thousands, maybe millions, of alternatives to Whatsapp for that purpose.

How many of those can my elderly mother use to talk to her sisters? By my estimation the answer is, "zero," and the alternatives will get even scarcer thanks to Bill C-22.

Signal is almost a 1:1 UI clone. If they can manage whatsapp they can manage signal...

Re: My main Android phone is now 99% Google free

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How many of those can my elderly mother use to talk to her sisters? By my estimation the answer is, "zero," and the alternatives will get even scarcer thanks to Bill C-22.

Signal is almost a 1:1 UI clone. If they can manage whatsapp they can manage signal...

Except my aunts are already on WhatsApp and I would have to get all of them on Signal. And then they would still need WhatsApp because of everyone else they talk to who isn't on Signal. The network effect is very real. On top of that we still don't know if Bill C-22 is going to require Signal to pull out of Canada entirely because of the metadata retention requirements. They don't keep metadata and that's something Canadian law enforcement has been pushing for for a long time.

Re: My main Android phone is now 99% Google free

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Signal is almost a 1:1 UI clone. If they can manage whatsapp they can manage signal...

Except my aunts are already on WhatsApp and I would have to get all of them on Signal. And then they would still need WhatsApp because of everyone else they talk to who isn't on Signal. The network effect is very real. On top of that we still don't know if Bill C-22 is going to require Signal to pull out of Canada entirely because of the metadata retention requirements. They don't keep metadata and that's something C…

>And then they would still need WhatsApp because of everyone else they talk to who isn't on Signal.

I don't see the issue. I do the exact same. Want to talk to me? Use this app or we can't. There never can be any network effect if nobody start doing this.

Post reply on HN