Live data from Hacker News

GitHub Is Down

githubstatus.com

41–50 of 61 posts

Re: GitHub Is Down

#41
post #29

Am I hallucinating or did they do a "cleanup" of the GH status in their status page? https://www.githubstatus.com/ API Requests with 4 nines of availability?? Issues with 99.96 uptime? PR with 99.61% uptime last 90 days?? https://mrshu.github.io/github-statuses/ marks PRs at 95.89% in the same period as an example.

https://www.githubstatus.com/incidents/x69zbgdyfzg0 took three days to resolve and isn't being counted as an outage on the official page.

[deleted]

Re: GitHub Is Down

#42

Am I hallucinating or did they do a "cleanup" of the GH status in their status page? https://www.githubstatus.com/ API Requests with 4 nines of availability?? Issues with 99.96 uptime? PR with 99.61% uptime last 90 days?? https://mrshu.github.io/github-statuses/ marks PRs at 95.89% in the same period as an example.

I clicked through wayback machine and couldn’t see any strong indicators that uptime had been rewritten, but there are a lot of snapshots. If you can prove it, I’m interested.

Re: GitHub Is Down

#43
post #19

This has gotten to a point where it doesn't really matter anymore. When a service crosses a certain reliability threshold it's like a phase change. The customer base eventually adapts to the situation. Anyone who still genuinely cares has moved to self hosted enterprise or something else by now. It was most tenuous for me when they almost met the SLA. Now that they've blown so far beyond it, the stress is mostly gone…

I care but I can't move out because it's Orders from Up High which migrated us to Github. We haven't been here a year and it's not worth my neck to mirror our code in some kind of skunkworks forge instance. Woe. Woe is me.

Our Big Giant Enterprise wants to move all our repos from ADO to GitHub for all the nifty AI features, but I'm told the frequent downtime is a major issue so we're slow-walking the migration.

Re: GitHub Is Down

#44
post #5

Once again, GitHub is down. Last time an incident happened was 2 days ago [0]. Could not have happened on a worse day (Monday) and you can see how unreliable GitHub has been. Better of self-hosting. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48418183

Anything I'd self-host would be down way more often than github.

Only for a scale approaching github's, otherwise a gitea instance or whatever doesn't have any interdependent components other than the server you host it on, which won't have nearly as low a downtime as github (though that's a low bar, a better way to phrase it would be saying it would pretty much never be down).

Re: GitHub Is Down

#46

Am I hallucinating or did they do a "cleanup" of the GH status in their status page? https://www.githubstatus.com/ API Requests with 4 nines of availability?? Issues with 99.96 uptime? PR with 99.61% uptime last 90 days?? https://mrshu.github.io/github-statuses/ marks PRs at 95.89% in the same period as an example.

I had checked that page not long ago, and as far as I remember there were many "red" or "orange" days in the past 3 months. Now it's all green. That's concerning

If they've actually improved the service, it would be fine. Is there reasonable plausability, reasonable doubt, or reasonable suspicion?

Re: GitHub Is Down

#47
post #30

Am I hallucinating or did they do a "cleanup" of the GH status in their status page? https://www.githubstatus.com/ API Requests with 4 nines of availability?? Issues with 99.96 uptime? PR with 99.61% uptime last 90 days?? https://mrshu.github.io/github-statuses/ marks PRs at 95.89% in the same period as an example.

Seems like if they changed the criteria of downtime. If you hover over the individual days you’ll see lot of degraded messages, but still green.

[deleted]

Re: GitHub Is Down

#48

Am I hallucinating or did they do a "cleanup" of the GH status in their status page? https://www.githubstatus.com/ API Requests with 4 nines of availability?? Issues with 99.96 uptime? PR with 99.61% uptime last 90 days?? https://mrshu.github.io/github-statuses/ marks PRs at 95.89% in the same period as an example.

I clicked through wayback machine and couldn’t see any strong indicators that uptime had been rewritten, but there are a lot of snapshots. If you can prove it, I’m interested.

As said, maybe I'm really hallucinating and mixed up the official and unofficial GH status pages, but there are definitely incidents published in the official one that are not counted as downtime or even partial degradation in the uptime counter.

Re: GitHub Is Down

#49

The Google SRE book offers the following as one of the reasons to not gun for 100% reliability (emphasis added): > users typically don’t notice the difference between high reliability and extreme reliability in a service, because the user experience is dominated by less reliable components like the cellular network or the device they are working with . Put simply, a user on a 99% reliable smartphone cannot tell the d…

Github isn't having a debate over how many 9s they have, they're having a zero 9s problem. I think there's 3 big themes with this, thought not 1. LLM tools have added considerable load. 2. LLM used by developers to increase velocity seem to be leading more outages. This calls into question the increased velocity. 3. Roadmaps focused on pushing features that aren't reliability problems. i.e. github moving to azure, or…

Your comment made me think: if GitHub was a Google product with similar popularity and scaling trajectory, would we see similar reliability issues?

Absolutely not. Google has reliability practices so deeply ingrained in their company they’re like an involuntary reflex.

This is a management issue.

Re: GitHub Is Down

#50

Soon we'll have to track when Github is up.

The London Underground have been doing it in reverse for a long time. "There is good service on the Piccadilly line."

The phrasing they chose is particularly amusing, since it's always false regardless of the day. They could have said "usual service", and left in the plausible acknowledgement of the fact that it's hot, cramped, miserable, grubby, loud, plague-ridden, mouse-ridden, and generally unpleasant.
Post reply on HN