Live data from Hacker News

What Is a Dickover?

daringfireball.net

41–50 of 227 posts

Re: What Is a Dickover?

#41
post #10

[flagged]

[flagged]

I'm not in this industry. I block basically everything. I think the state of these design antipatterns is terrible.

But this is a Chesterton's Fence problem and we need to understand where it came from if we're going to fix it.

Re: What Is a Dickover?

#42
post #10

[flagged]

It must be worth a lot for me to see it, because if I land on a site shopping for something, I might just turn around when you interrupt me and force me to actively not sign up for your email list.

You should turn around! That's literally my point.

If everyone refused to touch a site that blasts you with a dickover, they would disappear overnight. Clearly people do not do this enough, because it's still being implemented.

Re: What Is a Dickover?

#43
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If someone is allowed to shove something in front of my face should I not be allowed to make them invisible? Yes, I'm 100% on the adblock train. Local AI adblock sounds like a great solution. Then maybe dickovers will go away when the market realizes they don't work. That's the only way. What won't help is complaining that the largely free products we get don't work the way we want them to.

>What won't help is complaining that the largely free products we get don't work the way we want them to. This makes no sense and seems bad-faith on multiple levels.

On the contrary, I'm assuming good faith on the part of those who implement these "dark" patterns.

They're done for a reason, and that reason is not pure evil from their perspective.

Re: What Is a Dickover?

#44

Did you know that a Substack's author can turn the annoying popup off? Go to dashboard -> settings, and then it's "Enable subscribe prompts on post page" under "Growth." It's the first thing I did. Recommended.

We all know why they keep it on.

I’m just kind of surprised that it works to convert people.

Or…maybe it doesn’t?

Some of these things that we have are just common practices that owners of websites do that are seemingly done automatically without much thought to the experience.

Re: What Is a Dickover?

#45
I explicitly disable these on Substack but it adds them to my posts anyway. I'm not sure if that's a bug or the thing working as intended, but it was enough to make me stop using it. I don't want to do that to my readers.

Re: What Is a Dickover?

#46

I have a theory that about 97% of developers and managers completed the cookie consent (or whatever) on their own product 5 years ago and hence never see it again, and they have no idea how bad the experience for new customers actually is. So the developers and bosses all think they're doing a great job and they've got a carefully curated homepage, even though the regular users get a cloudflare captcha, then a cookie…

Always test your website in a private window.

Re: What Is a Dickover?

#47
Dickovers are annoying -- tell me, what's your solution? For me, a combination of a) not patronizing these sites, but when I have to b) some ad blockers help. Nothing seems to work well though.
Post reply on HN