Live data from Hacker News

Sergey Brin Confronted Gavin Newsom

bloomberg.com

41–50 of 62 posts

Re: Sergey Brin Confronted Gavin Newsom

#41
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you know the history of why California became a tech mecca?

Because of the Federal government heavily investing in Computer research at the Universities there and propping up the semiconductor industry?

Wait, I thought it was psychedelic drugs. What did the dormouse say, anyway?

Re: Sergey Brin Confronted Gavin Newsom

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except what’s stupid is thinking the marginal billions of dollars they may save by not paying CA taxes are worth anything. If you have $5Bn, other than power for power’s sake, it’s very hard to see how the next $100 or $500Bn can actually improve your life and happiness. OTOH, being able to watch a Broadway show that you may have missed because you didn’t live in the same city, or a drive along the ocean while there…

when you have this money you can “live” anywhere you want. he can have breakfast in Paris and still make the Broadway show and also get AirBnB for like a year in SF and then also like basically be wherever you want to be regardless of where your “mailing address” is. I have a friend who is 7-digit rich that lives in SF (for the past 8 years) but “lives” in Florida. sounds like our billionaires can’t figure this out s…

7-digit rich in SF is essentially any homeowner

Re: Sergey Brin Confronted Gavin Newsom

#43
post #9
post #5

[flagged]

They can leave. And they did.

One or two, nothing close to all. It's always an empty threat since time immemorial. Here's a 1936 FDR speech mocking it:

"A number of my friends who belong in the very high upper brackets have suggested to me on several occasions of late, that if I am reelected president, they will have to move to some other nation because of high taxes here. Now, I will miss them very much..." (audience breaks into laughter)

It's a manipulative tactic by greedy assholes to cow foolish people into accepting their demands of tax evasion to burden ordinary people.

Re: Sergey Brin Confronted Gavin Newsom

#45
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They can leave. And they did.

One or two, nothing close to all. It's always an empty threat since time immemorial. Here's a 1936 FDR speech mocking it: "A number of my friends who belong in the very high upper brackets have suggested to me on several occasions of late, that if I am reelected president, they will have to move to some other nation because of high taxes here. Now, I will miss them very much..." (audience breaks into laughter) It's a…

An estimated $1.1t ($800b confirmed) in taxable assets have already left.

Re: Sergey Brin Confronted Gavin Newsom

#46
Yeah so, how about that universal basic income where everyone whose job gets crushed by AI makes an income. But if only the billionaires have money they’re the only ones who can pay it. How do those guys like paying their share? (They don’t like it at all)

Re: Sergey Brin Confronted Gavin Newsom

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

shows you also how “smart” they are to “live” in Cali in the first place. you got billions, park yourself wherever the F you don’t have to pay jacksh t for being a billionaire prick and get yourselves on of them houses in Cali to actually live instead of whatever sh thole houses billionaires for free

Wealthy people pay the vast majority of taxes in California. Meanwhile, at least 20% of the population are complete freeloaders.

"Wealthy people pay the vast majority of taxes in California."

And well they should.

Anyone who dislikes a progressive tax system apparently wants billionaires to pay less and the poor to pay more.

Re: Sergey Brin Confronted Gavin Newsom

#48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I find it funny how bad faith commenters immediately reach for the "COMMUNISM" bugle the microsecond any tax increase for the ultra-wealthy is proposed. Taxes on the highest income bracket during Dwight D. Eisenhower's presidency where 90%. 90%. Ya know, during the 1950s. The so called "Golden Years" of the USA. Fiercely anti-communist, Cold War going on. And here we were taxing the richest at 90%. That's how I know…

Income vs wealth tax. These aren't comparable.

The amount paid by the proposed wealth tax is a paltry sum compared to the income tax. They absolutely are comparable.

Re: Sergey Brin Confronted Gavin Newsom

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One or two, nothing close to all. It's always an empty threat since time immemorial. Here's a 1936 FDR speech mocking it: "A number of my friends who belong in the very high upper brackets have suggested to me on several occasions of late, that if I am reelected president, they will have to move to some other nation because of high taxes here. Now, I will miss them very much..." (audience breaks into laughter) It's a…

An estimated $1.1t ($800b confirmed) in taxable assets have already left.

The billionaire mind virus might be contagious.

Re: Sergey Brin Confronted Gavin Newsom

#50

endless greed is remarkable. guys with $200B can't afford to pay taxes to the state that allowed them to gain such excessive wealth in the first place, often via government subsidy. this cancerous version of capitalism can't end quickly enough.

[flagged]

Everyone seems to be objecting to the arithmetic error, but what’s more interesting is the underlying assumption: that “Sergey Brin owes $50B” is so morally dispositive that it would end the argument.

Brin is not a sympathetic marginal case. He is the standard: founder equity, $1 salary, unrealized appreciation, deferral, and access to liquidity without needing wage income.

It is a little strange to look at a very large tax bill landing at his feet and decide that is where the scandal starts. Is the number supposed to make the idea disqualifying because it is drastically more than most people make in many lifetimes?

Said another way, the revealing part is not that someone on the internet multiplied wrong. The revealing part is how quickly the error resolves into a fairness argument on behalf of Sergey Brin, a man whose fortune is almost a laboratory specimen of the thing the regular income tax keeps failing, decade after decade, to reach.

Post reply on HN