Live data from Hacker News

NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)

columbian.com

41–50 of 84 posts

Re: NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)

#41
Unless they mean another "f word", the f word was used in Apollo 10. It's just that the transcripts change it to "freaking": > Oh, shit' What they did, they made it a two - Ain't this smart' Ain't that a smart freaking sack.

( https://apollojournals.org/afj/ap10fj/as10-day2-pt9.html )

It can be found in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DQVEsfa15SY

Re: NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)

#42

>Armstrong, Aldrin and Collins cursed fewer than 15 times during their moon-landing mission, based on NASA transcripts. Most of that came from command-module pilot Collins. Aldrin cursed just once and Armstrong didn’t at all. From what I've read about Armstrong, absolutely no surprise there.

Yeah he was apparently a great guy.

Re: NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A significant chunk of the population thinks they'll get tortured for eternity if they do it too much, and finds it distressing to be exposed to it as a result.

perhaps obviously, i am not and never have been religious. your comment brings up a point that i have never really thought about: why is it mostly religious people that are against swearing? does the bible or any religious text specifically call out swearing (beyond taking their gods name in vain, which i can understand avoiding if you are religious)?

Many religious texts have broader restrictions on word usage than just their deity's name in vain. Usually those are adjacent to other aspects of the religion. I am not aware of any that would forbid what we would commonly call swear words.

Re: NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)

#44

Growing up I never cursed. As an older teen and young adult I started to around my friends but never in the home around my family. Then I entered the military and very quickly cursing became deeply ingrained in my speech. To the point it was difficult to speak a entire sentence without a curse word. Towards the end I embraced religion heavily and made it a point to cut out cursing entirely. Nowadays I do not curse at…

They're just words . If you want to give those words so much power over you, that's your own problem to deal with. What right do you have to demand the rest of society cater to your particular hangups? When I hear curse words, they elicit exactly the same emotional response as any other word. There's nothing magical or inherently special about them, it's all in your own psychology.

Do you think the same about the n-word?

Re: NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)

#45

[flagged]

It's funny as a parent, because I'm expected to tell my son that he shouldn't curse even though his mom and I do. And all of our friends. And coworkers. And my boss. And his boss. And our CEO. And the fucking president. It's ridiculous.

I think the underlying needle this is trying to thread is teaching kids to know their audience and adjust their register for it (which is a much broader skill than just whether or not to curse), but I agree that the fucking president ;) doing it gives kids ammo to argue against the rule. Idk if that's a good or a bad thing, maybe just neutral.

Re: NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A significant chunk of the population thinks they'll get tortured for eternity if they do it too much, and finds it distressing to be exposed to it as a result.

perhaps obviously, i am not and never have been religious. your comment brings up a point that i have never really thought about: why is it mostly religious people that are against swearing? does the bible or any religious text specifically call out swearing (beyond taking their gods name in vain, which i can understand avoiding if you are religious)?

It's the same motivation as racists: they need some way to feel superior to the people that they despise. If the entire world stopped swearing today, these people would just find something else to use in their supremacist proxy wars.

Re: NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Using profanity indicates a weak vocabulary. A lack of discipline. this is just made up, though. not a lick of scientific backing to it.

Where's your scientific backing that it's not made up?

the keywords you want to put into google are "burden of proof".

Re: NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)

#48

[flagged]

It's funny as a parent, because I'm expected to tell my son that he shouldn't curse even though his mom and I do. And all of our friends. And coworkers. And my boss. And his boss. And our CEO. And the fucking president. It's ridiculous.

What is ridiculous is how funny it is when your three year old stubs his toe on the coffee table and yells "oh for fucks sake!", but you have to hide all that amusement.

Good job expressing yourself, little man. It was accurate and concise, but we're going to try not to say that.

Re: NASA had to train Apollo 11's astronauts to not use profanity (2019)

#50

[flagged]

It's funny as a parent, because I'm expected to tell my son that he shouldn't curse even though his mom and I do. And all of our friends. And coworkers. And my boss. And his boss. And our CEO. And the fucking president. It's ridiculous.

>his mom and I do. And all of our friends. And coworkers. And my boss. And his boss. And our CEO. And the fucking president.

>I'm expected

So, who's doing the expecting?

Only half joking: do him a favor and teach him to avoid the passive voice like that.

Post reply on HN