Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Spine Swarm (YC S23) – AI agents that collaborate on a visual canvas

getspine.ai

41–50 of 85 posts

Re: Launch HN: Spine Swarm (YC S23) – AI agents that collaborate on a visual canvas

#41

I think this is really neat. You should probably take it as a compliment that the biggest criticisms so far are about the website landing page. ;) I like canvases in general, and I especially like them for mentally organizing and referring to this sort of broad work. (Honestly, I think zoomable canvases would make a better window manager in general, but I digress) One small piece of friction: My default mouse-based w…

Really appreciate the detailed feedback and questions! And yes, we'll take the website criticism as a compliment :)

Good callout on the canvas navigation, we'll look into middle mouse button support.

To answer your questions: 1) GitHub integration is on our roadmap. Right now you can export outputs manually but we want to make this seamless. 2) All your canvases are saved and you can search them by name in your dashboard. We're also working on a dedicated section for deliverables across canvases. 3) Yes to both! You can manually add or edit blocks, or kick off new agent runs that build on existing work. 4) You can currently only share public links of your canvas to others (but you can make it private at any point). We are testing out a teams feature which allows you to share canvases with members on your team securely. Beyond that, we are working on adding roles and email-based sharing controls which is in our roadmap. 5) Claude Code in a block is a really interesting idea. We don't support that today but we're thinking about computer use and coding workflows. 6)BYOK (bring your own keys) is something we've heard interest in and are considering. Self-hosting isn't available right now, though we do support private deployments for enterprise customers if that's ever relevant. 7) Love the 'preferred web browser' framing. Right now you can search canvases but searchable artifacts across canvases is definitely where we want to head.

Thanks for giving it a real spin, this kind of feedback is incredibly valuable.

Re: Launch HN: Spine Swarm (YC S23) – AI agents that collaborate on a visual canvas

#42

Congrats on the launch! Meta comment, but I just ain't reading all of the above. You need to be able to explain this in about 20% the number of words or you'll lose people, especially VC. My advice is to start with "Spine Swarm solves _____" then how, then why you're different. 3 short paragraphs, preferably 1-2 sentences each.

Agreed. We will make sure this comes through in our website.

Re: Launch HN: Spine Swarm (YC S23) – AI agents that collaborate on a visual canvas

#44

Calling it a 'canvas' makes me think that this tool is about AI agents doing some kind of collaborative drawing. Looking at the vid though, it seems more like an environment for visually organizing and managing agentic work (which seems very cool, and quite a bit more than just a canvas).

Agreed. The term has been overloaded lately. We also refer to it as a visual workspace which perhaps captures it a bit better.

Re: Launch HN: Spine Swarm (YC S23) – AI agents that collaborate on a visual canvas

#45
I have not seen my final report yet for my query around machinist.com. However I would like to say my initial impression is very positive. At least in terms of the digestion of my somewhat nebulous request. I like the way your app was able to burrow down to pain points I have experienced and am trying to work out in terms of product market fit for the domain. I look forward to exploring more and giving you more feedback when I see the final report. I will also add that I am looking forward to using your product to explore other opportunities that I'm sure are out there in this age of AI.

Re: Launch HN: Spine Swarm (YC S23) – AI agents that collaborate on a visual canvas

#46
post #37

whoa congrats on the launch. lol I launched my visual canvas for agents today too. I went in a more of a collaborative canvas IDE, agent orchestration direction. But very cool to see your take on it https://getmesa.dev is mine

It looks interesting, but is it really more efficient than a tiling window manager?

Re: Launch HN: Spine Swarm (YC S23) – AI agents that collaborate on a visual canvas

#47

[flagged]

Great framing. You're right that context fragility is a big part of it. The canvas helps because each block maintains its own context explicitly, and connected blocks pass context between blocks without polluting the agents' context windows.

On conflict resolution, the synthesizer block can see all upstream outputs, so it has full visibility into any divergence. It does surface contradictions to the user, though this is something we're constantly improving.

Re: Launch HN: Spine Swarm (YC S23) – AI agents that collaborate on a visual canvas

#48
post #28

Interesting idea, I wanted to see an example of the agents working on a canvas when I opened your page. I saw nothing of the sort. Sorry, but immediate fail. This may be too harsh, but you need to make it immediately clear to someone today why they can't just have Claude Code one shot your app!

I read "AI agents that collaborate on a visual canvas" and I thought it was a shared canvas (as in an image) that virtual agents could contribute to, sort of like an image-only Moltbook.

Re: Launch HN: Spine Swarm (YC S23) – AI agents that collaborate on a visual canvas

#49

I have not seen my final report yet for my query around machinist.com. However I would like to say my initial impression is very positive. At least in terms of the digestion of my somewhat nebulous request. I like the way your app was able to burrow down to pain points I have experienced and am trying to work out in terms of product market fit for the domain. I look forward to exploring more and giving you more feedb…

This is great to hear, thank you! Would love to hear your thoughts once you see your final report and explore some of those other opportunities.

Re: Launch HN: Spine Swarm (YC S23) – AI agents that collaborate on a visual canvas

#50
"I make AI output lots of stuff" is not an intrinsically valuable thing. I can run the same thing on Claude in research mode and get a report with cited sources in a more digestable format on my phone. What's the eval here on if any of this is good? Is it even possible to test (ie, you cant really AB test startup ideas)?
Post reply on HN