Live data from Hacker News

70k Books Found in Hidden Library in This Germany Home (2023)

bookstr.com

41–50 of 81 posts

Re: 70k Books Found in Hidden Library in This Germany Home (2023)

#41
post #18

What is very surprising for me is the height of the books. If you look closer at the picture, seems that most of the books are the same height, so that's very strange for any book collection except if he was collecting the same book editors or... Am missing something ?

Space savings... when you get to those numbers it starts to matter and I think he just saw a shortcut because the same format books store more compactly together and usually print the same authors.

Re: 70k Books Found in Hidden Library in This Germany Home (2023)

#43
post #18

What is very surprising for me is the height of the books. If you look closer at the picture, seems that most of the books are the same height, so that's very strange for any book collection except if he was collecting the same book editors or... Am missing something ?

The infamous Bookshelf of Procrustes where every book fits - too tall books have their tops lopped off and too short books are stretched out.

Re: 70k Books Found in Hidden Library in This Germany Home (2023)

#44

I wish they had talked a bit more about how he managed to re-read any of the books, because from the pictures a great deal of them seemed like they were rather inaccessible.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsundoku

A friend of mine has mad Jenga style stacks of manga all over his flat and I will be forwarding this word to him.

Re: 70k Books Found in Hidden Library in This Germany Home (2023)

#45
post #5

I went to a local estate sale of a professor, whose entire downstairs (4+ rooms) was filled with bookshelves full of books. They were well organized by topic, and covered a range of topics (math, science, health, fiction, biographies, etc). It was more functional than artistic, comparing it to the pics in this post, but the number of books was probably the same order of magnitude as our local public library’s collect…

The thrift stores take them. No need for the dump.

My experience was different. Even the local library was dumping a lot of donated books, which was surprising since they did have book sales.

Re: 70k Books Found in Hidden Library in This Germany Home (2023)

#46
post #18

What is very surprising for me is the height of the books. If you look closer at the picture, seems that most of the books are the same height, so that's very strange for any book collection except if he was collecting the same book editors or... Am missing something ?

I think he sorted them by height. If you look closer you can see also shelfs with different sized books that were too non standard.

Re: 70k Books Found in Hidden Library in This Germany Home (2023)

#47
post #10
post #3

But you nobody can read 70k books, so what was the point? He had a library nobody knew about, full of books he hadn't read. That's not a library, it's an imitation of a library built by someone who doesn't understand what a library is for.

Not every book in a library is meant to be read like a novel. Some books need only be referenced, briefly and periodically.

The article doesn't say much about what was in the library, but it does mention that it contained 10,000 thriller novels.

Re: 70k Books Found in Hidden Library in This Germany Home (2023)

#48
post #30
post #18

What is very surprising for me is the height of the books. If you look closer at the picture, seems that most of the books are the same height, so that's very strange for any book collection except if he was collecting the same book editors or... Am missing something ?

I think the answer is in the article text "all meticulously sectioned by publisher". Book sizes differ somewhat between publishers, but each publisher tends to only print books in a few standard sizes. For the paperback editions this is even more reduced, it usually looks to me like all paperbacks from one publisher are the same size.

I never undertood why publishers couldn't agree in 5 different sizes or so.

Re: 70k Books Found in Hidden Library in This Germany Home (2023)

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The thrift stores take them. No need for the dump.

My experience was different. Even the local library was dumping a lot of donated books, which was surprising since they did have book sales.

Frankly, most titles are junk, like most TV shows are junk.

Re: 70k Books Found in Hidden Library in This Germany Home (2023)

#50
post #48
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the answer is in the article text "all meticulously sectioned by publisher". Book sizes differ somewhat between publishers, but each publisher tends to only print books in a few standard sizes. For the paperback editions this is even more reduced, it usually looks to me like all paperbacks from one publisher are the same size.

I never undertood why publishers couldn't agree in 5 different sizes or so.

Because they are an industry, aren’t they? Printing, binding, cover productions, transportation and storage, all that are much easier and much cheaper with a few standardized sizes.
Post reply on HN