Live data from Hacker News

Ed Zitron loses his mind annotating an AI doomer macro memo

dropbox.com

41–50 of 130 posts

Re: Ed Zitron loses his mind annotating an AI doomer macro memo

#41

> Commented [1]: what if pee pee was poo poo Rarely do I read something that starts off with such promise!

Don’t encourage his diaper fetish! [0] [0]: https://bsky.app/search?q=from%3Aedzitron.com+diaper

"Search is currently unavailable when logged out"

Re: Ed Zitron loses his mind annotating an AI doomer macro memo

#42

> Commented [1]: what if pee pee was poo poo Rarely do I read something that starts off with such promise!

Don’t encourage his diaper fetish! [0] [0]: https://bsky.app/search?q=from%3Aedzitron.com+diaper

I thought there would be one or two results, perhaps a result of poor reoccurring phrasing. Nope.

>i'm going to change your diaper and burp you

>Carlito is a very good boy Go piss in your diaper you big baby

>He doesn't care. He is a big baby who filled up his diaper with pee pee and poo poo

>you are a big baby and i am going to change your diaper and burp you >To be clear I call executives of multi trillion dollar companies scumbags and if you can't deal with that I'm not sure what to do. Burp you? Change your diaper?

>I am going to change your diaper and burp you

>Yeah man it's real authoritarian to say your second name is doodoo. Go change your diaper you big baby

>Yeah because you're a big baby with a big full diaper

>Hello sir this is your uber outside. I have your order from the diaper store

Re: Ed Zitron loses his mind annotating an AI doomer macro memo

#43
post #25
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Half of developers are below average. Half of developers say that the code Ai produces is amazing. Would you like a venn diagram?

You’re saying that AI is already good enough to replace 50% of developers. Sounds like you agree it will be very important.

He's saying the good half of developers have to deal with the increased slop output of the bad half. Probably will be overwhelmed by it, in the end.

Re: Ed Zitron loses his mind annotating an AI doomer macro memo

#44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>His argument has never been "this tech doesn't work", but rather "these businesses aren't economically viable" Why? because of cost?

Cost, debt, difficulty forming a moat, gap between what the product promises and what it can do, and the difficulty actually raising capital required. His style is acerbic and (imo) excessive sometimes. But he's also one of a minority of journos actually looking at the numbers and adding them up. Which seems to be a rarity

cost is going down 20x, 30x over the years so he's wrong about this.

Re: Ed Zitron loses his mind annotating an AI doomer macro memo

#45

The financial market things are over my head and I don't have a dog in the game, but I think "Nobody is replacing salesforce with their internally vibe coded software" is just false? Both taken literally [0] [1] and as denying the general trend. Just in my company we already replaced WMS software subscription with own solution, and I wouldn't be able to write it fast enough and maintain it by myself without the use o…

I didn't think something could be worse than everyone using Salesforce, but everyone using a different, constantly broken, incompatible SF clone that no one understands may be that.

Re: Ed Zitron loses his mind annotating an AI doomer macro memo

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cost, debt, difficulty forming a moat, gap between what the product promises and what it can do, and the difficulty actually raising capital required. His style is acerbic and (imo) excessive sometimes. But he's also one of a minority of journos actually looking at the numbers and adding them up. Which seems to be a rarity

cost is going down 20x, 30x over the years so he's wrong about this.

Those are very large reductions - can I ask you for a source?

And why is the error bar so large?

Re: Ed Zitron loses his mind annotating an AI doomer macro memo

#47

The original memo: https://www.citriniresearch.com/p/2028gic HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47114579

I'm somewhat halfway through the original memo, and I hate the fact that kernels of truth lie here and there. For example, I used to work as a full-stack developer for about 2 years, and now I got forced into what the memo calls "gig economy" just to pay the rent, because companies slowed down hiring junior developers thanks to... Honestly, I don't really care at this point what I have to thank for.

All I know is, whenever I read testimonies from people whose companies suddenly decided to force LLM usage for productivity to be "AI first", having colleagues opening PR's who are only machine reviewed with implementations they cannot justify themselves outside of "Claude wrote it", makes me burnout just reading them. And it's only going to get worse until it becomes better, but not for the developers.

Honestly, the one thing that I could see justify all the investment companies make for LLM-assisted coding is the full automation of software production. I can only see the current state of things as the "end game" for them, only if they suddenly decide to jack up pricing to tap directly on the corporate budget and not the individual developer's budget.

Re: Ed Zitron loses his mind annotating an AI doomer macro memo

#48
post #45

The financial market things are over my head and I don't have a dog in the game, but I think "Nobody is replacing salesforce with their internally vibe coded software" is just false? Both taken literally [0] [1] and as denying the general trend. Just in my company we already replaced WMS software subscription with own solution, and I wouldn't be able to write it fast enough and maintain it by myself without the use o…

I didn't think something could be worse than everyone using Salesforce, but everyone using a different, constantly broken, incompatible SF clone that no one understands may be that.

Lol give it 12 months.

Re: Ed Zitron loses his mind annotating an AI doomer macro memo

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

cost is going down 20x, 30x over the years so he's wrong about this.

Those are very large reductions - can I ask you for a source? And why is the error bar so large?

https://epoch.ai/data-insights/llm-inference-price-trends

> The rate of decline varies dramatically depending on the performance milestone, ranging from 9x to 900x per year

Re: Ed Zitron loses his mind annotating an AI doomer macro memo

#50
post #31
post #9

I do enjoy a good Ed Zitron sneer. The fact that the original article moved markets says a lot about the critical thinking skills of stock market traders.

You should look into how he destroyed the small indie MMO Darkfall and gave the game 2/10 without ever playing it, in a Eurogamer review a few years ago. The developers had receipts and could prove that he hadn't played it. It doesn't have any material effect on this article, but it says something about his ethics.

Its word against word in this situation. The logs prove nothing as they are easily modifiable and the devs had a good reason to do so.
Post reply on HN