Live data from Hacker News

Librarians tired of being accused of hiding secret books that were made up by AI

gizmodo.com

41–50 of 84 posts

Re: Librarians tired of being accused of hiding secret books that were made up by AI

#41
The "magic" of why AI is trusted over humans is that so many humans are terrible at their jobs that people default to not trusting someone who is telling them something they don't want to hear.

The AI always tells them what they want to hear, and so they trust it. It's not magic.

Re: Librarians tired of being accused of hiding secret books that were made up by AI

#42
post #20

Ah Gizmodo, always the paragon of good journalism. The person has explicitly asked her tweets not be used in external websites, and of course this zombie tabloid doesn't give a damn

Do not read this comment.

Wait...you're still reading, defying my T&Cs!

The tag to not display on external websites is up to Bluesky to enforce. I mean, you understand those Bluesky chirps or whatever are literally being served by Bluesky, right?

Re: Librarians tired of being accused of hiding secret books that were made up by AI

#43
post #6

I visited the local library (California foothills) during a “book sale”, and what didn’t sell was left out in boxes, either for cheap or free. What didn’t move was destined for the landfill. I was aghast, but without enough room to take in the strays. Real estate is unforgiving. I am in favor of “little free libraries” [0] where books circulate freely, and if they aren’t returned, hopefully are read and not destroyed…

My wife runs one locally. She's pretty happy with it, but I have to bite my tongue when talking about it with her. People frequently take all the good books, all at once, and don't return them. Someone just emptied out half of it yesterday, and I don't even think they were picky. They just took a whole shelf of books. It's such a crappy thing to do, and there's nothing that can be done to stop the bad actors.

Bad actors? Bad readers surely.

The trick is to plump up such a library with a few books no one will take. Cheap romances etc.

Re: Librarians tired of being accused of hiding secret books that were made up by AI

#44

Librarians do hide books. But not as a way of hiding from public but as a way of not throwing them away. Let me explain. Even though libraries are very big still they run out of space and regularly throw out (in India because most don't care) / ( or in Texas sell out books cheaply) and it pains the librarians deeply so they kind of stash books secretly from being thrown away. And if you really show interest in a part…

They used to say that one of the chief roles of a librarian was to keep people away from books. There is a lot of truth in that.

Re: Librarians tired of being accused of hiding secret books that were made up by AI

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Judging books by their unborrowedness is like judging a youtube video's educational content by its view count. It's a bad reality created by the powers that be

Why have shelves full of books that haven’t been borrowed in 15 years? what benefit is that providing?

You can find entertaining stuff there. My interests can be really niche. I remember once finding an amazing book in our college library from the sixties or seventies about the use of LSD in treating psychiatric disorders. While I didn't agree with all the suggestions in there, it was a fascinating time capsule (with colour illustrations, many of them by patients). With the microdosing debate, it's probably relevant again.

Yet when I took the book off the shelf it looked like no one had touched it in many years.

Re: Librarians tired of being accused of hiding secret books that were made up by AI

#47
post #6

I visited the local library (California foothills) during a “book sale”, and what didn’t sell was left out in boxes, either for cheap or free. What didn’t move was destined for the landfill. I was aghast, but without enough room to take in the strays. Real estate is unforgiving. I am in favor of “little free libraries” [0] where books circulate freely, and if they aren’t returned, hopefully are read and not destroyed…

My wife runs one locally. She's pretty happy with it, but I have to bite my tongue when talking about it with her. People frequently take all the good books, all at once, and don't return them. Someone just emptied out half of it yesterday, and I don't even think they were picky. They just took a whole shelf of books. It's such a crappy thing to do, and there's nothing that can be done to stop the bad actors.

A lot of the bad actors are scanning prices on them and selling them. Deface the title page and inside covers and they will be fine to read but worth almost nothing at sale. A stamp saying "Taken from the Little Free Library of X. Share and enjoy. Please report sellers." would do the job.

Re: Librarians tired of being accused of hiding secret books that were made up by AI

#48
post #18

This seems to have a simple solution - if you can't find any reference to a particular book by googling its title, then it likely does not exist.

You have too much faith in Commissar Google. I know of numerous books which don't appear on Google. Likely the tip of the iceberg.

Re: Librarians tired of being accused of hiding secret books that were made up by AI

#49
post #20

Ah Gizmodo, always the paragon of good journalism. The person has explicitly asked her tweets not be used in external websites, and of course this zombie tabloid doesn't give a damn

The person who has that setting is the user being quoted, not the top-level post; the bluesky is indeed blocking that post in question, so it isn't appearing on Gizmodo

See here :https://skyview.social/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fbsky.app%2Fprofile...

Re: Librarians tired of being accused of hiding secret books that were made up by AI

#50
post #20

Ah Gizmodo, always the paragon of good journalism. The person has explicitly asked her tweets not be used in external websites, and of course this zombie tabloid doesn't give a damn

Do not read this comment. Wait...you're still reading, defying my T&Cs! The tag to not display on external websites is up to Bluesky to enforce. I mean, you understand those Bluesky chirps or whatever are literally being served by Bluesky, right?

it is being 'enforced' by the bsky embed, the post not shown is the quoted one: https://skyview.social/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fbsky.app%2Fprofile...
Post reply on HN