Live data from Hacker News

Tom Stoppard has died

bbc.com

41–50 of 78 posts

Re: Tom Stoppard has died

#41
post #10

I wrote an extended essay on “Rosencranz and Guildenstern Are Dead” in high school… 1998-1999 period. I loved his screenplays even though I’m not a great fan of theatre in general. 88 is a ripe old age but it’s still deeply saddening.

> “Rosencranz and Guildenstern Are Dead” I love that movie. Never got to see it on stage though, which I've read was superior.

The film is really the best it gets. It's perfect.

Re: Tom Stoppard has died

#43
Rosencrantz: Is that southerly?

Guildenstern: We came from roughly south.

Rosencrantz: Which way is that?

Guildenstern: In the morning, the sun would be easterly. I think we can assume that.

Rosencrantz: That it's morning?

Guildenstern: If it is, and the sun is over there for instance, that would be northerly. On the other hand, if it's not morning and the sun is over there, that would still be northerly. To put it another way, if we came from down there, and it's morning, the sun would be up there, but if it's actually over there and it's still morning, we must have come from back there, and if that's southerly, and the sun is really over there, then it's the afternoon. However, if none of these are the case...

Rosencrantz: Why don't you go and have a look?

Guildenstern: Pragmatism. Is that all you have to offer

R and G are dead is a true gem of the English language. Strongly recommend the film!

Re: Tom Stoppard has died

#45
post #10

I wrote an extended essay on “Rosencranz and Guildenstern Are Dead” in high school… 1998-1999 period. I loved his screenplays even though I’m not a great fan of theatre in general. 88 is a ripe old age but it’s still deeply saddening.

> “Rosencranz and Guildenstern Are Dead” I love that movie. Never got to see it on stage though, which I've read was superior.

Well, Stoppard himself directed the movie.

Re: Tom Stoppard has died

#46
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They absolutely did, and German science never recovered its former dominant position after Hitler. People don't even realize that as late as 100 years ago, Americans would travel to Germany for first-class university education. Harvard was good for networking and decent for overall education, but top notch science was done in places like Heidelberg.

Its still the case today, its just that America has gotten louder about its academic accomplishments being a key factor in economic success. Your average German/Austrian universities have plenty of ex-pat Americans, there for precisely the fact that the education systems have such variety between the two nations. They are understated and under-represented in mainstream culture about academia, but for sure there are s…

America buys a lot of people in for its universities today, although of course there are bright Americans. German universities today are stricter and more rigorous in general than American ones.

I think the USA, like the UK, does tend to use name recognition. Oxford and Cambridge use interviews to filter out people, but are disproportionately represented in power structures.

Re: Tom Stoppard has died

#47
post #43

Rosencrantz: Is that southerly? Guildenstern: We came from roughly south. Rosencrantz: Which way is that? Guildenstern: In the morning, the sun would be easterly. I think we can assume that. Rosencrantz: That it's morning? Guildenstern: If it is, and the sun is over there for instance, that would be northerly. On the other hand, if it's not morning and the sun is over there, that would still be northerly. To put it a…

Rosencrantz: Do you think Death could possibly be a boat?

Guildenstern: No, no, no... Death is "not." Death isn't. Take my meaning? Death is the ultimate negative. Not-being. You can't not be on a boat.

Rosencrantz: I've frequently not been on boats.

Re: Tom Stoppard has died

#48
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While I get you're trying to highlight jkr's anti-trans opinion, both can be true. You can be an asshole, while also being subject to other assholes behavior.

I read all of her tweets but I don't know of any anti-trans statements by Rowling. I'd appreciate it if you could point one out. I haven't heard her say that there's anything wrong with being trans, that it's an illness, or that there should be any consequences. I have heard her decry the excesses of some trans activists and allies, particularly in her defense of women-only spaces. That seems to me to be a poor fit f…

I mean it’s pretty straightforward - due to trauma over her past experiences with sexual assault at the hands of cis men, she now sees trans women as a facade used by predatory cis men to sexually assault cis women in bathrooms and locker rooms and other segregated spaces.

To her, trans women are really cis men pretending to be women, to make it easier to rape them. There’s kind of no nice way of saying it.

It’s textbook transphobia / queer bashing. Fear of sexual assault at the hands of queer people is probably one of the most basic reasons to justify this particular brand of bigotry. “I don’t hate queers, I’m just concerned for the safety of -“ take your pick - women, children, sometimes even men. For JK it’s women.

Re: Tom Stoppard has died

#49
post #38

"She has been subjected to an onslaught of abuse that highlights an insidious authoritarian and misogynistic trend." -- Tom Stoppard on J.K. Rowling

While I get you're trying to highlight jkr's anti-trans opinion, both can be true. You can be an asshole, while also being subject to other assholes behavior.

[flagged]
Post reply on HN