Live data from Hacker News

Copenhagenize Index 2025: The Global Ranking of Bicycle-Friendly Cities

copenhagenizeindex.eu

41–50 of 119 posts

Re: Copenhagenize Index 2025: The Global Ranking of Bicycle-Friendly Cities

#41
post #26
post #23

The biggest hurdle to biking for me is parking safely. Unless I can park it behind locked doors I have an anxious feeling that it may not be still there when I return. This is no problem when bicycling to work, but for arbitrary errands it is. A good lock helps of course, but it still feels like a gamble.

In the Netherlands you just chain it to something then you’re fine. Otherwise it’s gone in 60 seconds.

Pro tip: just ride an old and rusty omafiets that nobody wants, no need for a chain.

Re: Copenhagenize Index 2025: The Global Ranking of Bicycle-Friendly Cities

#42

Bicycling is part of the mobility culture of Montreal, but whether Montreal is actually friendly to bicyclists is open to heated debate. Cars dominate the topology.

Montreal's city leaders might be friendly. Its climate is not. Once the snow falls, the number of bicycle commuters plummets towards zero. Paris, vancouver, the netherlands ... they have stable climates condusive to bike use. At -10 it isnt the cars that will cause a crash, it is the physics of a two rubber wheels trying to navigate on ice.

Also, Quebec is not a city. The city is called "Quebec City" just as how New York and New York City are very different places.

Re: Copenhagenize Index 2025: The Global Ranking of Bicycle-Friendly Cities

#43

It is currently -1 to -3 in Montreal and -2 to -7 in Quebec (city). So yes folks literally freezing. It will remain so (down to -35) for the next 4 months.

Helsinki hits more or less the same weather, people cycle there just fine. It's only a matter of infrastructure and gear.

According to Wikipedia, the mean daily minimum of Helsinki in January is -5.6°. In Quebec City, it’s -17.7°. Not the same, at least according to Wikipedia.

Re: Copenhagenize Index 2025: The Global Ranking of Bicycle-Friendly Cities

#45

It is currently -1 to -3 in Montreal and -2 to -7 in Quebec (city). So yes folks literally freezing. It will remain so (down to -35) for the next 4 months.

Eh, biking in the cold isn't really worse than walking in the cold. The snow is a bigger issue.

Re: Copenhagenize Index 2025: The Global Ranking of Bicycle-Friendly Cities

#46

It is currently -1 to -3 in Montreal and -2 to -7 in Quebec (city). So yes folks literally freezing. It will remain so (down to -35) for the next 4 months.

People wear appropriate clothing for the weather. Those temperatures are no reason to stop biking. People do not "literally" freeze when it's below 0.

Re: Copenhagenize Index 2025: The Global Ranking of Bicycle-Friendly Cities

#47
post #26
post #23

The biggest hurdle to biking for me is parking safely. Unless I can park it behind locked doors I have an anxious feeling that it may not be still there when I return. This is no problem when bicycling to work, but for arbitrary errands it is. A good lock helps of course, but it still feels like a gamble.

In the Netherlands you just chain it to something then you’re fine. Otherwise it’s gone in 60 seconds.

That strongly depends on the city and the places you park your bike. I've never needed to chain my bike, although I do it for new bikes because insurance demands it.

There are neighborhoods in cities like Amsterdam where bicycle theft is pretty much expected to happen no matter how many locks you buy, but in smaller towns there's barely a need to lock your bike at all during the day.

Re: Copenhagenize Index 2025: The Global Ranking of Bicycle-Friendly Cities

#48

It is currently -1 to -3 in Montreal and -2 to -7 in Quebec (city). So yes folks literally freezing. It will remain so (down to -35) for the next 4 months.

Helsinki hits more or less the same weather, people cycle there just fine. It's only a matter of infrastructure and gear.

Yes I agree but in general we dont have infrastructure and it gets much colder. Salt doesnt work at some point so you dont have dry pathways.

Re: Copenhagenize Index 2025: The Global Ranking of Bicycle-Friendly Cities

#49
post #22

Ranking Bordeaux and Nantes next to Amsterdam is nonsense. Amsterdam is miles ahead in terms of infrastructure. This ranking dilutes the most important thing to get these results : good bike lancés everywhere with no discontinuity. Disclaimer : I've built villes.plus, an open source automated evaluation of bike lanes. 100 points, compute itineraries in "secure" mode with Brouter between these points, count the % of s…

Fun fact Amsterdam recovers roughly 15000 cycles per year from their canal. IIRC they have a board with the number for each year

Re: Copenhagenize Index 2025: The Global Ranking of Bicycle-Friendly Cities

#50

It is currently -1 to -3 in Montreal and -2 to -7 in Quebec (city). So yes folks literally freezing. It will remain so (down to -35) for the next 4 months.

People wear appropriate clothing for the weather. Those temperatures are no reason to stop biking. People do not "literally" freeze when it's below 0.

It gets much colder than zero. With blinding northern winds. Yes a human can do anything but is it desirable?
Post reply on HN