Many days I worry that HN has lost its humanity and then something with a bit of levity and weird shows up and I am relieved.
Opposite reaction, this article reads like it was written by a care bear.
Underrated reasons to be thankful V
41–50 of 106 posts
Re: Underrated reasons to be thankful V
#42Point #2 ("somewhat less fit... on average") is totally inaccurate if the parents are statistically average in the modern/Western world. It's accurate if the parents are extraordinary, in which case all children will likely be less extraordinary. It may be accurate in conditions of high infant mortality. I'm not sure if point #29 is supposed to be a joke. If it's a joke, it's in exceedingly poor taste. Polybius had i…
The worst thing out there are those arrogant folks who think they know better than everybody else and go and try to create some sort of (self-centered) utopia, based on flawed expectations who we humans are, ignoring basic human traits we all share like selfishness. The more anybody tries to stick out of grand design and forge their own way (or even god forbid criticize), the harsher they are put down to not spoil the paradise.
I'd take democracy and freedom with corresponding risks and rewards any day over that.
Re: Underrated reasons to be thankful V
#43This whole thing reads strange. I’m not thankful for any of the presented reasons to be thankful.
Re: Underrated reasons to be thankful V
#44Re: Underrated reasons to be thankful V
#45Yes, it’s weird and eclectic and not at all mainstream, but those of us like that got to stick together!
Re: Underrated reasons to be thankful V
#46Re: Underrated reasons to be thankful V
#47Earlier quoted context omitted.
Opposite reaction, this article reads like it was written by a care bear.
Lots of religious over- and undertones going on, I assume that's where you get the vibe
Re: Underrated reasons to be thankful V
#48Re: Underrated reasons to be thankful V
#49This whole thing reads strange. I’m not thankful for any of the presented reasons to be thankful.
Re: Underrated reasons to be thankful V
#50Point #2 ("somewhat less fit... on average") is totally inaccurate if the parents are statistically average in the modern/Western world. It's accurate if the parents are extraordinary, in which case all children will likely be less extraordinary. It may be accurate in conditions of high infant mortality. I'm not sure if point #29 is supposed to be a joke. If it's a joke, it's in exceedingly poor taste. Polybius had i…
Too harsh on democracy, literally everything else is much worse. Attested by enormous suffering of tens of billions humans before or now who could only dream of freedoms like you have here, criticizing it openly without mortal fear of repressions on you and your loved ones. The worst thing out there are those arrogant folks who think they know better than everybody else and go and try to create some sort of (self-cen…
Ancient Greek-style democracy -- where every citizen votes on every important issue -- can now be implemented in the US and any European country, with ease. It's not like we don't have the technology. Why do we need corrupt intermediaries? To simplify things a bit, it is because we're going to get oligarchy or ochlocracy, and the oligarchs want to make sure they're on the winning team, whereas direct democracy is a path to ochlocracy within a mere handful of years.
The Ancients knew all of this, of course.
All that said, a state's form of government has very little (in some cases nothing) to do with that state's ability to benefit from material progress.
It's a real laugh to suggest that our ancestors were "suffering enormously" on account of the fact that they were ruled by a feudal lord who descended from his mountain fortress once a year to collect taxes in the form of a handful or two of grain. Our ancestors had a place, a duty, a strong faith, and a connection to their superiors and inferiors. Large families, festivals and feast days, homes full of music. On balance, they were probably happier than modern man.