Live data from Hacker News

Asus Ascent GX10

asus.com

41–50 of 203 posts

Re: Asus Ascent GX10

#41

Any good ideas for what these can be used for? I am still trying to think a use case that a Ryzen AI Max/MacBook or a plain gaming gpu cannot cover.

A GPU cluster would work better but if you're only testing things out using CUDA and want 200GB networking and somewhat low power all in one this would be the device for you

Re: Asus Ascent GX10

#43
post #6

Looks like a pretty useful offering, 128Gb Memory Unified, with the ability to be chained. IN the Uk release price looks to be £2999.99 Nice to see AI Inference becoming available to us all, rather than using a GPU ..3090etc. https://www.scan.co.uk/products/asus-ascent-gx10-desktop-ai-...

All Sparks only have a memory bandwidth of 270 GB/s though (about the same as the Ryzen AI Max+ 395), while the 3090 has 930 GB/s. (Edit: GB of course, not MB, thanks buildbot)

The 3090 also has 24gb of ram vs 128gb for the spark

Re: Asus Ascent GX10

#44

I wonder why they even added this to the FAQ if they're gonna weasel their way around it and not answer properly? > What is the memory bandwidth supported by Ascent GX10? > AI applications often require a bigger memory. With the NVIDIA Blackwell GPU that supports 128GB of unified memory, ASUS Ascent GX10 is an AI supercomputer that enables faster training, better real-time inference, and support larger models like LL…

Probably LLM slop, but also it's the same GB10 chip as the DGX Spark so why would the memory bandwidth be significantly different?

As far as I can tell these are all the same hardware just different enclosures. I'm not sure why Nvidia went this route given that they have a first party device. Usually you only see this when the original manufacturer doesn't want to be in the distribution or support game.

Re: Asus Ascent GX10

#45

"Nvidia dgx os", ugh. It would be a lot more enticing if that thing could run stock Linux.

I assume the driver code just isn't in mainline linux and installing the correct toolchain isn't always easy. Having it turnkey available is nice and fundamentally new hardware just isn't going to have day 1 linux support.

You're free to lift the kernel and any drivers/libraries and run them on your distribution of choice, it'll just be hacky.

Re: Asus Ascent GX10

#46
GX10 vs MacBook Pro M4 Max:

- Price: $3k / $5k

- Memory: same (128GB)

- Memory bandwidth: ~273GB/s / 546GB/sec

- SSD: same (1 TB)

- GPU advantage: ~5x-10x depending on memory bottleneck

- Network: same 10Gbe (via TB)

- Direct cluster: 200Gb / 80Gb

- Portable: No / Yes

- Free Mac included: No / Yes

- Free monitor: No / Yes

- Linux out of the box: Yes / No

- CUDA Dev environment: Yes : No

Re: Asus Ascent GX10

#47
post #6

Looks like a pretty useful offering, 128Gb Memory Unified, with the ability to be chained. IN the Uk release price looks to be £2999.99 Nice to see AI Inference becoming available to us all, rather than using a GPU ..3090etc. https://www.scan.co.uk/products/asus-ascent-gx10-desktop-ai-...

All Sparks only have a memory bandwidth of 270 GB/s though (about the same as the Ryzen AI Max+ 395), while the 3090 has 930 GB/s. (Edit: GB of course, not MB, thanks buildbot)

Eh, this is way overblown IMO. The product page claims this is for training, and as long as you crank your batch size high enough you will not run into memory bandwidth constraints.

I've finetuned diffusion models streaming from an SSD without noticeable speed penalty at high enough batchsize.

Re: Asus Ascent GX10

#48

Funny to wakeup and see this on the front page - I literally just bought a pair last night for work (and play) somewhat on a whim, after comparing the available models. This one was available the soonest & cheapest, CDW is giving 100 off even, so 2900 pre tax.

I presume this is not yet in your possession. Please do let us know how it goes.

Nope not shipped/processed yet even. It was listed as in stock with a realistic number though!

Re: Asus Ascent GX10

#50

What a shame. This would have been a much more powerful machine if it was wrapped around AMD products. At least with this, you get to pay both the Nvidia and the Asus tax!

In this case the Asus "tax" is negative $1,000.
Post reply on HN