Live data from Hacker News

Dead soldiers' teeth reveal diseases that doomed Napoleon's army

washingtonpost.com

41–50 of 85 posts

Re: Dead soldiers' teeth reveal diseases that doomed Napoleon's army

#41

Check out the perfect set of teeth on the skull of the soldier shown in the article. Amazing how human dental health has changed since then.

1. The soldier probably died young

2. Good dental health has always been part of the screening to join a professional army

Re: Dead soldiers' teeth reveal diseases that doomed Napoleon's army

#42

It is interesting that although Napoleon captured Moscow, the capital at that time was in Saint-Petersburg. Why didn't he go to the capital? This painting depicts Napoleon hopelessly waiting for a delegation from Russian Emperor with burning city in the background [1]. [1] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Napoleon_in_burning_...

One theory I've heard for this, and sorry I don't remember the source, is that Napoleon suspected if he truly did take down the Russian royalty then he expected the rest of European royalty to unite and attack attack him.

As I remember, after French revolution, there were coalitions of foreign monarchies with the goal of punishing France [1].

Also what surprises me, after years of several revolutions and chaos in France, how could Napoleon gather such a large army.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_of_the_First_Coalition

Re: Dead soldiers' teeth reveal diseases that doomed Napoleon's army

#43

> Salmonella enterica is a bacterium that causes enteric or paratyphoid fever and is acquired by ingesting contaminated food or water. > Borrelia recurrentis is a bacterium that causes relapsing fever, which is transmitted by body lice. Saved you a click

How did you save me a click? Those bits were in this article. The guy that located the original report saved me some time.

You could only save somebody time if they skipped the content and started doing comments on HN anyhow, but that’s not all the information either, just a couple key points.

Re: Dead soldiers' teeth reveal diseases that doomed Napoleon's army

#44

It is interesting that although Napoleon captured Moscow, the capital at that time was in Saint-Petersburg. Why didn't he go to the capital? This painting depicts Napoleon hopelessly waiting for a delegation from Russian Emperor with burning city in the background [1]. [1] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Napoleon_in_burning_...

Your comment has me remember a great graph of his army disintegrating. It’s such a good visualisation.

https://brilliantmaps.com/napoleons-invasion-infograhic/

Re: Dead soldiers' teeth reveal diseases that doomed Napoleon's army

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One theory I've heard for this, and sorry I don't remember the source, is that Napoleon suspected if he truly did take down the Russian royalty then he expected the rest of European royalty to unite and attack attack him.

As I remember, after French revolution, there were coalitions of foreign monarchies with the goal of punishing France [1]. Also what surprises me, after years of several revolutions and chaos in France, how could Napoleon gather such a large army. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_of_the_First_Coalition

he essentially invented the modern concept of conscription. there were press gangs and conscription-like things all through history but for the most part soldiers were professionals

Re: Dead soldiers' teeth reveal diseases that doomed Napoleon's army

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are figuratively killing me with your literalism.

These days some would've written, "you are literally killing me . . ." (which I find deplorable).

Using "literally" figuratively or, more precisely, as a hyperbolic intensifier [0], is a tradition employed by notable English writers who lived and died long before you were born.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literally

Re: Dead soldiers' teeth reveal diseases that doomed Napoleon's army

#48
post #15
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Look in any dictionary and you'll find that that decimate means to devastate aswell. Language is what people speak not what people proscribe in books or the internet.

If frequency of use is an argument, one could argue that to decimate might not even be a word.

Correct. To decimate is the infinitive form of the verb decimate.

Re: Dead soldiers' teeth reveal diseases that doomed Napoleon's army

#49
post #43

> Salmonella enterica is a bacterium that causes enteric or paratyphoid fever and is acquired by ingesting contaminated food or water. > Borrelia recurrentis is a bacterium that causes relapsing fever, which is transmitted by body lice. Saved you a click

How did you save me a click? Those bits were in this article. The guy that located the original report saved me some time. You could only save somebody time if they skipped the content and started doing comments on HN anyhow, but that’s not all the information either, just a couple key points.

> You could only save somebody time if they skipped the content and started doing comments on HN anyhow

as is customary

Re: Dead soldiers' teeth reveal diseases that doomed Napoleon's army

#50
It is also interesting that Russian army officers could talk to French without a translator, because Napoleon invasion happened in the period of "westernization", started by Peter the Great. The buildings were built in a Western style, calendar was changed to European, government, army and fleet were reformed, noblemen were required to shave their traditional beards, wear western-style clothes, used French language, and danced to classical Western music in events like balls and fought duels.
Post reply on HN