Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

My gf thinks videogames cannot be art. What to show her?

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

41–48 of 48 posts

Re: My gf thinks videogames cannot be art. What to show her?

#41

Post by Gerard0 »

evanjrowley wrote: post #14

>detective/case solving TV, fantasy Elder Scrolls (Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim) and Soulsborne (Demons Souls, Dark Souls, Bloodborne, Elden Ring) games both have lots of mysterious lore and fantasy elements. Maybe the lore videos would help her appreciate the art? Lore videos could also pique her interest in a video game without her actually having to play it, which could be a gateway to eventually getting a contolle…

Thanks a lot for this reply!

I don't know if you enjoy such games, but I also found here on HN some 2 player games like It takes two. Perhaps she would enjoy it? The story itself is not my cup of tea but I still think the game is great.

Re: My gf thinks videogames cannot be art. What to show her?

#44

Post by tobinfekkes »

Gerard0 wrote: post #39
tobinfekkes wrote: post #20

Portal

One or two? I remember reading here on HN that one (or both?) of them is great. I never got to play them myself.

I was debating whether to specify which one, but then decided I would leave ambiguous.

Frankly, they're both great. I think I have more of an affinity to Portal 1, not because it's "better", but because it was first. That was a very distinct moment in my memory when the game mechanics "click" at the beginning, and you realize what's going on and there's no other game world like it.

Re: My gf thinks videogames cannot be art. What to show her?

#46

Post by ChoGGi »

Gerard0 wrote: post #34
btschaegg wrote: post #12

If she has little experience with video games, Journey and Gris might be good candidates. For a more "technical" argument how gameplay mechanics can be a unique way to deliver an emotion to the player (arguably a major part in the role of art): Brothers: A Tale of two Sons. You'd have to make sure that she finishes it, though (estimate: ~3h). Two trippy games that defy categorization (but won't be good examples for s…

Never heard of any of these. Checked them out and they all look great. Hard to decide but I think I will include one of yours. Thanks a ton!

Going into it blind; Journey is a special treat.

If she is a fan of detective stories, then you wish to look into L.A. Noire or Shadows of Doubt.

Ori and the Blind Forest

Jusant or Tiny Glade have a distinct look.

Edit: Not art but for two player games, try Lovers in a Dangerous Spacetime, Untitled Goose Game, or Trine.

Re: My gf thinks videogames cannot be art. What to show her?

#48

Post by Tarsul »

Gerard0 wrote: post #47
Tarsul wrote: post #43

If I had to pick just one it would be Gorogoa. Just look at it, it plays even better. https://www.gog.com/en/game/gorogoa

This looks amazing! I will get it either way! Thanks!

Very good. Since she likes art/paintings, I could suggest Behind The Frame: The Finest Scenery. It has a great narrative and doesn't take too long (2h). Not sure if I would put it in the top3 but thats your decision anyway. Good luck. South of The Circle is another narrative game which left me pondering. I think thats the perfect genre for her anyway, whether she uses the word art or not ;)

PS: Please post the result of the competition :D

Post reply on HN