Live data from Hacker News

IRonCub: A Humanoid Robot Designed to Fly Like Iron Man

spectrum.ieee.org

41–50 of 55 posts

Re: IRonCub: A Humanoid Robot Designed to Fly Like Iron Man

#44

I really feel like people need to stop trying to make these sorts of robots look so "human-like". The effect of a mouthless bald doll head strapped on top of an iron man robot isn't exactly comforting, to me anyway. It starts to hit the uncanny valley a bit

I think they could make it a bit more professional looking like: https://imgur.com/a/vXED98B Like a friendly yet stern Butler of the Skies.

Re: IRonCub: A Humanoid Robot Designed to Fly Like Iron Man

#45

Can we please be honest with ourselves for a second and call out the ridiculousness of the "find a lost hiker" and "disaster relief" excuses used by kill-bot companies? Who is this robot going to save with glowing hot turbine engines on it's fore-arms. This is kill-bot tech put on the iCub to get articles in circulation.

It's dual use technology. It can and will be used to find lost hikers, it's just that it can also be used for nefarious purposes.

Re: IRonCub: A Humanoid Robot Designed to Fly Like Iron Man

#46
post #8

I really feel like people need to stop trying to make these sorts of robots look so "human-like". The effect of a mouthless bald doll head strapped on top of an iron man robot isn't exactly comforting, to me anyway. It starts to hit the uncanny valley a bit

This looks like it was put together by Sid in his room.

That was exactly what I thought of too when I saw it, hahaha. If it wasn't terrifying enough already...

Re: IRonCub: A Humanoid Robot Designed to Fly Like Iron Man

#47
post #4

I really feel like people need to stop trying to make these sorts of robots look so "human-like". The effect of a mouthless bald doll head strapped on top of an iron man robot isn't exactly comforting, to me anyway. It starts to hit the uncanny valley a bit

I feel like the funny part is that there are so many "robot" mask designs in pop culture that would look 1000x more comforting than a slightly psychotic looking robotic doll

Everything about this design feels wrong. Like they went out of their way to make it unappealing.

Re: IRonCub: A Humanoid Robot Designed to Fly Like Iron Man

#48
post #27
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Presumably they want to eventually put a human inside it [..] I'm imagining a team just putting the organs of a human into the robot to save on space. Basically a brain plus whatever is absolutely necessary to run the brain.

Wasn't that Robocop 3?

[deleted]

Re: IRonCub: A Humanoid Robot Designed to Fly Like Iron Man

#49
This goes into my "Top 100 really dumb things I've seen this year" list. Not sure if it makes top ten. It's definitely in the top 25%.

OK. Why?

Let's forget then "Let's strap model airplane jet engines to the robot and make it fly." part.

For this dumb mechanical albatross to be anywhere close to useful in ANY scenario, even without flying...it has to be useful as a humanoid robot. It isn't. iCub was a cool concept, but it is so far behind the current state of the art I am not sure why they are trying to make it fly.

And, flying?

You can hang a humanoid from any of the already available mega quadcopters and drop it off anywhere within the flight range.

You can probably stick a parachute on an already available humanoid and drop dozens of them from an airplane.

Flying is a solved problem. A humanoid useful in the real world --particularly in disaster areas-- is not. At all.

Post reply on HN