Live data from Hacker News

Pasta Cooking Time

jefftk.com

41–50 of 211 posts

Re: Pasta Cooking Time

#41
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pasta water being strachy is a good myth. It only happens in restaurants where they reuse the water all day long for many servings of pasta.

If you cook it in a lot less water, and add a quarter teaspoon of corn starch, you can get the same effect. Play with the ratios to taste.

I prefer to use semolina, since that's the same flour the pasta is made of. I find corn starch can add an "off" flavor.

Re: Pasta Cooking Time

#42
Hopefully tptacek shows up... this is sort of offtopic but made me remember some comments of his from years ago here on HN. Something about the "rehydrating" step not having to be the same as the "cooking" step. I feel like he said you could end up with some pretty interesting and terrific pasta by _soaking_ it for a while (not cooking it), and then cooking it for a much shorter time later.

Does this ring a bell for anyone? I've been wanting to try it, but I can't remember the details exactly.

Re: Pasta Cooking Time

#43
> I generally find the numbers printed on pasta boxes for cooking time far too high: I'll set the timer for a minute below their low-end "al dente" time

Interesting! I generally add three minutes to the recommended cooking time, otherwise the pasta still feels stiff. There's no accounting for taste, is there?

Re: Pasta Cooking Time

#44
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don't know why this was downvoted. My best pasta comes from when I start testing it roughly 9 minutes in. Pasta softness depends on water softness, salinity, even ambient air pressure (though I am decidedly a low-lying person). Also pasta shape, and even quantity of pasta in the container (unless you have one of those huge boilers used in restaurants). The instructions on the box tend to overcook my pasta well beyond…

Isn't De Cecco pretty mid? It's found in every supermarket in the UK for example

It’s a high quality mass market brand. I have tried a large number of more expensive brands, but none have beat De Cecco for me in terms of consistency and quality.

Re: Pasta Cooking Time

#46
post #24

The cooking time is proportional to the thickness. General advice on pasta: * a quality dry pasta (dececco e.g) will have ~14 grams of protein per 100 grams dry weight, this is really essential * bronze die cut will help soak up more sauces * you do not need the full volume of water the box says, but start your timer once the water has returned to a boil * once it has gotten to a boil, keep it boiling, but it doesn't…

Pasta water being strachy is a good myth. It only happens in restaurants where they reuse the water all day long for many servings of pasta.

... if you use less water than the amount prescribed on the box it'll be proportionally starchier. It isn't a myth, you can literally see the starch in the water ...

Re: Pasta Cooking Time

#47
"I boiled some water, put in the pasta, and starting at 9min I removed a piece every 15s until I got to 14:30:"

When you remove pasta, you Cool down the water. So its not the same reault as actual 15 minutes cooking

Re: Pasta Cooking Time

#49

The cooking time is proportional to the thickness. General advice on pasta: * a quality dry pasta (dececco e.g) will have ~14 grams of protein per 100 grams dry weight, this is really essential * bronze die cut will help soak up more sauces * you do not need the full volume of water the box says, but start your timer once the water has returned to a boil * once it has gotten to a boil, keep it boiling, but it doesn't…

> * if you're finishing in a sauce, take the pasta out a minute before it is done.

ie, 2-3 minutes before the box time, possibly more, depending on what finishing means for your case.

> * do not put oil in your cooking water, it will NOT help it not stick.

It will not hurt, and may help. Oil will stop the super starchy water, if you followed the reduce the water volume step as suggested, from boiling over - as it will help reduce the surface tension. This is real, and particularly important for some types of noodles and dumplings.

> Remember to reserve one cup of the starchy cooking water before draining your pasta entirely

At least- again, depending on what sauce you're putting it in, and how underdone you took it out. Particularly if you'll have leftovers (as any good homecook often will!), the 'al dente' pasta will absorb all your water, and you'll need to add some before you put it in the fridge, or it will be super dry when you reheat it.

> it does not need to be "salty like the ocean"

despite what Nigella might tell you, it should be no where near ocean water. (just to reinforce this, because I'm not sure if people just think it is a thing to say, or they just have no idea how salty the sea is)

Re: Pasta Cooking Time

#50
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Based on the article, this seems like a recipe for overcooking pasta.

why would it be a recipe for overcooking pasta when it doesn't even mention cooking time but "check regularly and taste" ? that's basically what I do with French quality brands, it's between 9-11 min for dry pasta, when I make my own ravioli, it's more 2-3min

But what the OP wrote was not "check regularly and taste". They proposed a single timer-based check at one minute less than the time on the box.

That strategy relies on the box being off by at most one minute, so the results from the article seem highly relevant.

Post reply on HN