Live data from Hacker News

Gmail goes offline with Google Gears

gmailblog.blogspot.com

41–50 of 55 posts

Re: Gmail goes offline with Google Gears

#41
post #11
post #2

Google gmail goes off line with google gears (official google blog entry) s/gmail/Gmail s/off line/offline s/gears/Gears s/google/Google/g

If you're going to nitpick over something, nitpick over the link being to the front page of the blog, not to the blog post. (Maybe by the time people reading this tomorrow follow the link, Google will have posted something else.)

And get your nickpick right! It should be "s/gmail/Gmail/" with a trailing slash.

Re: Gmail goes offline with Google Gears

#42
post #13

This is undoubtedly great work from a technical standpoint, but I see the real value here for other types of web apps. Since gmail already supports imap, you could've been managing your mail from a number of free mail clients offline. Just like how Google Maps touched off the ajax craze, this may be more about ushering in a new archetype of offline apps beyond email.

The problem with managing your email from other clients, at least to me, is that other email clients have workflows that don't work with my expectations. I'm so used to using the Gmail key bindings that I find working in Apple Mail or Thunderbird slow and painful. The lack of a native Archive metaphor in those clients causes me further pain. I funnel almost all of my email into Gmail and gave up on local email client…

My sentiment exactly. What I would really want is a good email client, like Thunderbird but with Gmail workflow - so at least it will support grouping emails by conversation ( but not the way TB does it). I wonder why no one implemented that yet.

Re: Gmail goes offline with Google Gears

#43
While I agree with the coolness quotient, and the technological marvel, here is one for the skeptics:

I, being an infrequent traveller, am almost always online - whenever I am using my laptop, that is. In the age of always-online-everywhere, how many people really find this useful?

Re: Gmail goes offline with Google Gears

#44

While I agree with the coolness quotient, and the technological marvel, here is one for the skeptics: I, being an infrequent traveller, am almost always online - whenever I am using my laptop, that is. In the age of always-online-everywhere, how many people really find this useful?

You may be online everywhere you go, but believe me, wi-fi is not everywhere yet, and often where it is, it's slow and/or broken.

I, for one, welcome our new offline e-mail overlords. :-)

Re: Gmail goes offline with Google Gears

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google's audience for reader and docs are in the millions and could hardly be described as "small", just like Gmail has a lot more than "thousands" of users :)

You understood my point :) But gmail vastly outnumbers docs and reader in both security and scale. Thousands of emails and contacts with personal information. Docs and Reader doesn't need to store the contacts or emails of the user. Docs stores data and reader stores stores. You can understand the security complications.

While I agree with you about Reader, I doubt the security implications for Gmail are much more severe than for Docs, because so many businesses are using Docs through Google Apps, and you know they're storing sensitive info on there. One breach and it's over.

Re: Gmail goes offline with Google Gears

#47
post #18

This solves my biggest problem with managing my GOogle account over iMap. When I tried to set it up with Apple Mail I ran into the issue of each label being treated as a folder. This meant that for each label a duplicate of the message was created meaning that I could have up to 4 different copies of any single email.

I had a very similar problem with Thunderbird. I couldn't find my mail half of the time. I gave up in the end and now just access the web interface.

Re: Gmail goes offline with Google Gears

#48
post #31
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been waiting for this feature for a really long time. Reminds me of 2005 when I was waiting for them to come out with Calendar and waiting for someone to come out with easy video publishing. Was so happy to see these products get made. The fact that Google controls all my data makes me less happy.

Rather them than any other company in my opinion.

Than any other single company.

Re: Gmail goes offline with Google Gears

#49
post #15

Gears is great. "Flaky connection mode" is even better.

I've been waiting for this feature for a really long time. Reminds me of 2005 when I was waiting for them to come out with Calendar and waiting for someone to come out with easy video publishing. Was so happy to see these products get made. The fact that Google controls all my data makes me less happy.

It makes me _more_ happy :-)

Rather them than me.

Re: Gmail goes offline with Google Gears

#50
Now all it needs is a "Combine conversations" button. hint hint

Great feature though, I'm sure this will get more people to install Gears and ensure it's not a "lost cause" for Google. I'm sure Gears is a big part of their strategy for the web now.

Post reply on HN