Live data from Hacker News

Teenagers no longer answer the phone: Is it a lack of manners or a new trend?

phys.org

41–50 of 68 posts

Re: Teenagers no longer answer the phone: Is it a lack of manners or a new trend?

#41

I'm in my late 30's and if it was possible I would block all incoming calls, except those from a whitelist. Never seen it prescribed to manners if someone picks up a phone or not. Is that a US thing?

FYI you can “silence unknown callers” on the iPhone, just search under settings. Then your whitelist is people you have in your contacts. Maybe Android has a similar setting too, I don’t know though.

Re: Teenagers no longer answer the phone: Is it a lack of manners or a new trend?

#42

I'm in my late 30's and if it was possible I would block all incoming calls, except those from a whitelist. Never seen it prescribed to manners if someone picks up a phone or not. Is that a US thing?

American here. Definitely not a US thing. Most likely the headline is an attempt to gin up some controversy clicks.

Just because someone calls me, doesn’t mean I’m obligated to answer it.

Re: Teenagers no longer answer the phone: Is it a lack of manners or a new trend?

#44
Gen Z here. Personally I’m glad to get a call from a close friend any time. Especially when it serves the purpose of them just telling me about something funny or interesting that has happened, to discuss some issue where tone of our speech is an essential part of communication, or to organize some get-together and make plans. In such cases I actually appreciate getting the call and happily pick up the phone. I only don’t if it’s an unknown number, or if the person repeatedly only calls to ask for a favor. Robocalls I don’t get often.

I agree with the argument presented here that one can communicate more effectively by intentionally not making oneself available right away and allowing oneself to be silent first. I totally relate to this in cases where e.g. a friend is asking for advice. However I feel that this is used mostly as an excuse to avoid communication. I don’t think there is a non-negligible proportion of teenagers that really think to themselves “hmm this matter calls for some contemplation, I should answer later”, rather “I really don’t want to deal with this right now”. I also feel that, similarly, what I see in the comments here is less “I don’t answer calls so that I communicate more effectively”, rather “I don’t answer because I don’t want to be bothered with real human interaction”, and I think that’s just sad. How can someone take such pride in intentionally isolating and disconnecting himself?

Re: Teenagers no longer answer the phone: Is it a lack of manners or a new trend?

#45

I'm in my late 30's and if it was possible I would block all incoming calls, except those from a whitelist. Never seen it prescribed to manners if someone picks up a phone or not. Is that a US thing?

> Never seen it prescribed to manners if someone picks up a phone or not. Is that a US thing?

I would see it analogous to someone in real-life saying hi and the other person ignoring them. Is that rude? Depends on your relationship with the person. A salesman? No. Someone you're really close to? Maybe; depends on your relationship with them. Boss? Likely.

It also depends on whether you call back, in case you were driving or something.

> "When I see 'Dad mobile' pop up on my screen, I will let it ring. I don't have the energy to answer a barrage of questions. I'd rather just text him after he hangs up," says 16-year-old Mehdi.

If they didn't text back, I might see it as reasonable grounds for some type of punishment, depending on a number of factors (time of day, where they're supposed to be, how they've been behaving lately, etc.).

Another comment talked about not being obligated to answer, but towards one's parent when they're a teen? This is one of those relationships where they would have an obligation to answer.

Re: Teenagers no longer answer the phone: Is it a lack of manners or a new trend?

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What did you say???

I was praising her strengths but I guess they weren’t the areas she wants to be strong in. So she perceived it as not being important in those other areas.

I think they were pulling your leg.

Re: Teenagers no longer answer the phone: Is it a lack of manners or a new trend?

#47
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was praising her strengths but I guess they weren’t the areas she wants to be strong in. So she perceived it as not being important in those other areas.

I think they were pulling your leg.

Unfortunately not, but it’s all good now.

Re: Teenagers no longer answer the phone: Is it a lack of manners or a new trend?

#48
I do answer any call, but I am never introducing myself, nor using affirmative words. The moment I will figure out I have got an advertisement call, I am immediately hanging up. So I a not surprised that teenagers are not answering calls - it is very likely advertisement.

Re: Teenagers no longer answer the phone: Is it a lack of manners or a new trend?

#49

If it's a routine call from a service provider or what have you I'll also let it ring but this from the article is crazy to me: "When I see 'Dad mobile' pop up on my screen, I will let it ring. I don't have the energy to answer a barrage of questions. I'd rather just text him after he hangs up," says 16-year-old Mehdi. I'm twice that old and I'm not letting my parents or family hang if they call. What if they're in t…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN