Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Forklifts require training

zacsweers.dev

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

41–45 of 45 posts

Re: Forklifts require training

#41

Post by Karrot_Kream »

GJim wrote: post #39
sokoloff wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hacker News is social media. It just lacks a pretty UI and is overall less vapid.

Not this again. Social media is where one shares one's social life (it's in the name!). Granted there is often crossover between technical discussion forums and social media (I'm thinking of a motorbike forum I frequent), but to suggest the likes of HN is social media is rather silly. Isn't it.

> Social media is where one shares one's social life (it's in the name!).

So TikTok isn't social media because most people don't lost content and those that do rarely post about their social life?

Twitter isn't social media because most people don't post about their social life?

Re: Forklifts require training

#42

Post by sokoloff »

GJim wrote: post #39
sokoloff wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hacker News is social media. It just lacks a pretty UI and is overall less vapid.

Not this again. Social media is where one shares one's social life (it's in the name!). Granted there is often crossover between technical discussion forums and social media (I'm thinking of a motorbike forum I frequent), but to suggest the likes of HN is social media is rather silly. Isn't it.

I've always thought of it (and seen it defined) as media where the content is generated, liked, and commented upon by users (i.e. socially) rather than the media being controlled by a small group serving in an editorial role (traditional media).

Usenet is (IMO) the original social media. Very few usenet groups had anything to do with sharing one's social life.

Re: Forklifts require training

#43

Post by GJim »

Karrot_Kream wrote: post #41
GJim wrote: post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not this again. Social media is where one shares one's social life (it's in the name!). Granted there is often crossover between technical discussion forums and social media (I'm thinking of a motorbike forum I frequent), but to suggest the likes of HN is social media is rather silly. Isn't it.

> Social media is where one shares one's social life (it's in the name!). So TikTok isn't social media because most people don't lost content and those that do rarely post about their social life? Twitter isn't social media because most people don't post about their social life?

> So TikTok

Is a video sharing platform.

> rarely post about their social life

Note your correct use of the word rarely and consider my comment about crossover.

> Twitter

Xitter is a 'micro' blogging site.

> most people don't post about their social life

Again, note your observation of the most common uses of that platform and consider my comment about crossover.

Re: Forklifts require training

#45

Post by Karrot_Kream »

GJim wrote: post #43
Karrot_Kream wrote: post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Social media is where one shares one's social life (it's in the name!). So TikTok isn't social media because most people don't lost content and those that do rarely post about their social life? Twitter isn't social media because most people don't post about their social life?

> So TikTok Is a video sharing platform. > rarely post about their social life Note your correct use of the word rarely and consider my comment about crossover. > Twitter Xitter is a 'micro' blogging site. > most people don't post about their social life Again, note your observation of the most common uses of that platform and consider my comment about crossover.

Based on my understanding of your comment, the crossover exceptions dominate the discriminative power of the categories, so the taxonomy feels useless.
Post reply on HN