Live data from Hacker News

Vector Tiles are deployed on OpenStreetMap.org

blog.openstreetmap.org

41–50 of 73 posts

Re: Vector Tiles are deployed on OpenStreetMap.org

#41

Oh but that default style for Shortbread is so ugly! No contrast, missing details and lots of information lost. Hopefully it's vector tiles and information are there (I checked in Maputik) so it's possible to create my own style (which I will definitely try).

There is also the MapTiler OMT style for OpenMapTiles, which uses Vector Tiles. It is a close copy of the Standard OSM map style. It appeared at the same time as Shortbread on the osm.org website.

Re: Vector Tiles are deployed on OpenStreetMap.org

#42

Oh but that default style for Shortbread is so ugly! No contrast, missing details and lots of information lost. Hopefully it's vector tiles and information are there (I checked in Maputik) so it's possible to create my own style (which I will definitely try).

There is also the MapTiler OMT style for OpenMapTiles, which uses Vector Tiles. It is a close copy of the Standard OSM map style. It appeared at the same time as Shortbread on the osm.org website.

I agree, it's super close to the classical OSM style, but some things are missing, e.g. roads that are currently planned or in the building phase.

Re: Vector Tiles are deployed on OpenStreetMap.org

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hmm I tried the shortbread layer and while it looks nice it still pixelates when zooming in until it loads the new zoom level

I guess you're right. I see the same on my desktop Firefox on Linux. But on my Android phone it's pretty smooth.

It seems to just not work in Firefox for me, it's the same for me on FF Android but in Chrome it's beautiful! Constant text size while zooming and it's super smooth.

Edit: It also weirdly doesn't work on Chrome on Linux for me either, only Chrome on android. Oh well, hopefully they can bring support everywhere eventually.

Re: Vector Tiles are deployed on OpenStreetMap.org

#44

Oh but that default style for Shortbread is so ugly! No contrast, missing details and lots of information lost. Hopefully it's vector tiles and information are there (I checked in Maputik) so it's possible to create my own style (which I will definitely try).

There is also the MapTiler OMT style for OpenMapTiles, which uses Vector Tiles. It is a close copy of the Standard OSM map style. It appeared at the same time as Shortbread on the osm.org website.

Yeah. MapTiler has much better styles in general.

Re: Vector Tiles are deployed on OpenStreetMap.org

#45

Oh but that default style for Shortbread is so ugly! No contrast, missing details and lots of information lost. Hopefully it's vector tiles and information are there (I checked in Maputik) so it's possible to create my own style (which I will definitely try).

Yeah only motorways are highlighted everything else is faded in background.

Re: Vector Tiles are deployed on OpenStreetMap.org

#46
post #36
post #33

Many important details are not visible anymore: - gates on private pathways - shop names

Personally I'm quite happy that these tiles cut down on the clutter in the original OSM tiles. It made it very hard for me to actually use them for navigation because there was just so much stuff everywhere. For example the old tiles displayed rail tracks extremely prominently, which just aren't relevant 99% of the time even when traveling by train. In the vector tiles they're much more muted and thinner.

Yes but this one only highlights motorways which are used usually just for long distance drives.

Re: Vector Tiles are deployed on OpenStreetMap.org

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

More like OSM Database -> PNGs -> PNG Decoder in browser-> Your screen vs OSM Database -> Vector Tiles -> MaplibreGL.js -> WebGL -> Your Screen

Could you please comment on any security implications of executing community-generated vector tile content, compared to classic PNG decoding?

The security surface area will be either the png decoder or webgl, both are pretty well scrutinized but if I had to pick I would the png decoder is less likely to have a security issue compared to webgl.

Does't really matter because both png or webgl are available to any website at anytime.

Re: Vector Tiles are deployed on OpenStreetMap.org

#48
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is also the MapTiler OMT style for OpenMapTiles, which uses Vector Tiles. It is a close copy of the Standard OSM map style. It appeared at the same time as Shortbread on the osm.org website.

I agree, it's super close to the classical OSM style, but some things are missing, e.g. roads that are currently planned or in the building phase.

Yes, buildings under construction aren't there yet either. OMT is OpenSource though, so you can make a pull request: https://github.com/openmaptiles/openmaptiles

Re: Vector Tiles are deployed on OpenStreetMap.org

#49
post #33

Many important details are not visible anymore: - gates on private pathways - shop names

The choices are tough, also in details: Which shops to show in busy areas at which zoom level? But mind: openstreetmap.org is ment as a developer site, for developers to see their changes quickly. The official idea is that other people should take the data and do "nice" things elsewhere. But of course reality is that users want to use openstreetmap.org as alternative to Google maps ...

All the more reason to show rather more than less data.
Post reply on HN