Live data from Hacker News

WWDC25: macOS Tahoe Breaks Decades of Finder History

512pixels.net

41–50 of 88 posts

Re: WWDC25: macOS Tahoe Breaks Decades of Finder History

#41
Actually, for me, on the current icon, I see the "guy on the right", the "smiley face" is secondary.

On the new icon, I see a "smiley face", and if I concentrate a little, there's a "guy in the background".

I like the newer icon.

And, to be fair, this is the most thought I've ever put into it. So, there's that as well to consider.

Re: WWDC25: macOS Tahoe Breaks Decades of Finder History

#42
It's less evocative of Picasso, which is the whole point of the logo. Evoking Picasso as inspiration is (or, was) part of Apple's brand identity since the 90s because it suggests:

* Brilliant artists use Apple.

* Apple computers help you see from multiple perspectives.

But now that Apple is more in the business of selling bling to strippers and drug dealers, and less in the business of selling gear to creative professionals, sticking to its aesthetic identity is way less important. Not when there are concerns like "blowing up on TikTok" to worry about.

Re: WWDC25: macOS Tahoe Breaks Decades of Finder History

#43
post #17

I wish it would break history and let Spotlight and show me the path for the file it has found. Is it 2023/accounts.xlsx or 2024/accounts.xlsx or 2025/accounts.xlsx? Who knows!

Alfred will show you the full path of the search results

https://www.alfredapp.com/

Re: WWDC25: macOS Tahoe Breaks Decades of Finder History

#44
post #22

If they really want to improve MacOS they should add synonym based search in Settings. I should not be forced to know by heart the arcane speech their marketing department chose to replace consecrated terms. Just today it took me 5 minutes to unearth the Speech Rate settings. It feels like using Siri and not knowing the magic words. Come on Apple, synonym matching is easy. Just use a LLM to generate synonyms to all t…

I filed a bug report about a specific setting, "Screen Time" that stopped showing up in Finder, and a couple-few weeks later, it returned to being findable once more.

Filing bug reports about specific instances might be a useful way to help fix this?

Re: WWDC25: macOS Tahoe Breaks Decades of Finder History

#45
post #27

Without reading the text, it took me a solid three minutes to realize the difference in the comparison screenshot. Honestly I'm more upset by the non-centered window title.

Why would they do that? I didn't notice at first, but now that I've seen it, it's too distracting. Feels like change for the sake of change.

I believe the titles on iOS's alerts are also left aligned now. Saw it in the preview videos.

Re: WWDC25: macOS Tahoe Breaks Decades of Finder History

#46
I don't mind the change of colors or materials. But that padding in the icon just breaks the whole thing.

This obession of Apple with leaving space is absurd.

In Sequoia they added a window management system which (by default) leaves spaces between windows. What was the point of getting more display real state in laptops to waste it like this?

Re: WWDC25: macOS Tahoe Breaks Decades of Finder History

#47
post #22

If they really want to improve MacOS they should add synonym based search in Settings. I should not be forced to know by heart the arcane speech their marketing department chose to replace consecrated terms. Just today it took me 5 minutes to unearth the Speech Rate settings. It feels like using Siri and not knowing the magic words. Come on Apple, synonym matching is easy. Just use a LLM to generate synonyms to all t…

I would prefer if they re-organized their settings to actually be discoverable, instead of requiring search every time I need to change something.

(Because, yes, I feel your pain.)

Re: WWDC25: macOS Tahoe Breaks Decades of Finder History

#48
post #10

FTA: “The Finder logo has changed over the years, but the dark side has been on the left forever.” So, ‘forever’, they subtly associated left-handedness with the dark side? About time that they changed that ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bias_against_left-handed_peopl... ) :-)

Left handedness is sinister.

Ha, we also use those designations in organic chemistry for designating chirality in molecules.

Re: WWDC25: macOS Tahoe Breaks Decades of Finder History

#49
post #19

[flagged]

There is a whole lot of pearl clutching happening in this thread over an icon. It’s a tale as old as time. Apple makes “brave” design decision, Internet in uproar.

In the interest of being more constructive and adding to the discourse however, I will mention that the UX of things should increase as design frameworks should age. Are there quantifiable UX metrics that can be used (even if somewhat qualitative in nature) to judge whether a new design is a regression or not? Is it just AB testing?

Post reply on HN