Live data from Hacker News

NotebookLM Audio Overviews are now available in over 50 languages

blog.google

41–50 of 108 posts

Re: NotebookLM Audio Overviews are now available in over 50 languages

#41
NotebookLM podcasts are like a caricature of a real podcast. Every little verbal technique or narrative style that might be used by a normal podcaster in a subtle way is taken to an extreme.

The last one I listened to one host would repeat a keyword or phrase the other host had just said for emphasis — except they did incessantly — with multiple words in every sentence for many sentences in a row.

Re: NotebookLM Audio Overviews are now available in over 50 languages

#42

https://support.google.com/notebooklm/answer/15731776 - Afrikaans - Albanian - Arabic - Armenian - Azerbaijani - Basque - Bengali - Bulgarian - Burmese (Myanmar) - Catalan - Cebuano - Chinese (Simplified) - Chinese (Traditional) - Croatian - Czech - Danish - Dutch - English - Estonian - Filipino - Finnish - French (Canada) - French (European) - Galician - Georgian - German - Greek - Gujarati - Haitian Creole - Hebrew…

> Persian

I'm glad the name of my native language is written correctly. In many cases, people say "Farsi", which is offensive to many Iranians because it's the Arabic version of the word "Parsi" (unlike Persian, Arabic doesn't have "p", "g", "ch", "zh").

It's like someone calling English "Anglaise" because that's how the French say it.

PS: Contrary to common belief, Persian and Arabic are totally different languages, though they have borrowed words from one another (think English and French). Persian is an Indo-European language whereas Arabic is Aramaic (same roots as Hebrew).

Re: NotebookLM Audio Overviews are now available in over 50 languages

#43

https://support.google.com/notebooklm/answer/15731776 - Afrikaans - Albanian - Arabic - Armenian - Azerbaijani - Basque - Bengali - Bulgarian - Burmese (Myanmar) - Catalan - Cebuano - Chinese (Simplified) - Chinese (Traditional) - Croatian - Czech - Danish - Dutch - English - Estonian - Filipino - Finnish - French (Canada) - French (European) - Galician - Georgian - German - Greek - Gujarati - Haitian Creole - Hebrew…

> Persian I'm glad the name of my native language is written correctly. In many cases, people say "Farsi", which is offensive to many Iranians because it's the Arabic version of the word "Parsi" (unlike Persian, Arabic doesn't have "p", "g", "ch", "zh"). It's like someone calling English "Anglaise" because that's how the French say it. PS: Contrary to common belief, Persian and Arabic are totally different languages,…

Small nitpicking, Arabic is from a different branch of Semitic languages than Aramaic or Hebrew (which are very similar).

And TIL I learned that Aramaic replaced Hebrew in Judea because the Persian Empire maintained Aramaic as the official administrative language, and Jews brought it back, coming back from the Babylonian captivity.

Re: NotebookLM Audio Overviews are now available in over 50 languages

#44
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

cool, thanks for the wall of text.

There's a collapse feature (the [-] link at the top of the post)

It's still far too much for a HN comment.

You have to scroll down a couple pages' worth before you even realize this might be SO long you need to collapse it. So then you've got to scroll back UP a couple pages, find the teensy [-] link...

It's enough to just post the link to the list of languages. The list itself doesn't belong in a comment here, when it's that long.

Re: NotebookLM Audio Overviews are now available in over 50 languages

#45

https://support.google.com/notebooklm/answer/15731776 - Afrikaans - Albanian - Arabic - Armenian - Azerbaijani - Basque - Bengali - Bulgarian - Burmese (Myanmar) - Catalan - Cebuano - Chinese (Simplified) - Chinese (Traditional) - Croatian - Czech - Danish - Dutch - English - Estonian - Filipino - Finnish - French (Canada) - French (European) - Galician - Georgian - German - Greek - Gujarati - Haitian Creole - Hebrew…

> Persian I'm glad the name of my native language is written correctly. In many cases, people say "Farsi", which is offensive to many Iranians because it's the Arabic version of the word "Parsi" (unlike Persian, Arabic doesn't have "p", "g", "ch", "zh"). It's like someone calling English "Anglaise" because that's how the French say it. PS: Contrary to common belief, Persian and Arabic are totally different languages,…

Interesting. This is the first time I’m hearing that Farsi is offensive to Iranians. None of my Irani friends have objected so I’m curious if I’m missing something.

Wikipedia says Farsi should be avoided in Western languages, but what about others? Persian is called Farsi in Indian subcontinent due to the deep historical connections we share. We have proverbs saying Farsi is the sign of a learned person etc.

Re: NotebookLM Audio Overviews are now available in over 50 languages

#46
post #6

Do people find NotebookLM useful? For my use case of converting papers into podcasts, the explanations are too general (which misses the important parts of the paper) and contain too much fluff. I suspect that changing the underlying model to Gemini 2.5 Pro would produce better transcripts, but right now there's no way of determining what model is being used.

I find NotebookML really useful as a book reading companion, by simply uploading the same book I want to read and asking questions about it, like: - List the characters in chapter [x] and add a small description about each one. - What's [x] device used for? - What happened in chapter [x]? It works very well without hallucinations and referencing all the answers.

[flagged]

Re: NotebookLM Audio Overviews are now available in over 50 languages

#47
I tried it with Japanese, and it sounded about as good as in English. Only at one point did it sound unnatural. Japanese two-person conversation uses a lot of backchannelling (aizuchi), that is, semilinguistic sounds made by the listener to indicate attention and emotional reaction. At one point, the female voice said very distinctly "fumu fumu," which is how such aizuchi might be written in a script or manga. In actual speech, though, it would be a continuous sound without syllables and with a rising and/or falling intonation.

That brief TTS-like moment was the only time I was reminded that the voices were not human.

Re: NotebookLM Audio Overviews are now available in over 50 languages

#48

https://support.google.com/notebooklm/answer/15731776 - Afrikaans - Albanian - Arabic - Armenian - Azerbaijani - Basque - Bengali - Bulgarian - Burmese (Myanmar) - Catalan - Cebuano - Chinese (Simplified) - Chinese (Traditional) - Croatian - Czech - Danish - Dutch - English - Estonian - Filipino - Finnish - French (Canada) - French (European) - Galician - Georgian - German - Greek - Gujarati - Haitian Creole - Hebrew…

> Persian I'm glad the name of my native language is written correctly. In many cases, people say "Farsi", which is offensive to many Iranians because it's the Arabic version of the word "Parsi" (unlike Persian, Arabic doesn't have "p", "g", "ch", "zh"). It's like someone calling English "Anglaise" because that's how the French say it. PS: Contrary to common belief, Persian and Arabic are totally different languages,…

> It's like someone calling English "Anglaise" because that's how the French say it.

That is the case for some other languages, though. We call the language German rather than Deutsch because Germani was the Latin name for tribes in the area, for example.

Or native names get modified too -- in English we don't call it Espanish, just Spanish, even though it comes from español.

The names of languages in other languages tend to get modified in tons of different and random ways for lots of reasons. Is there really a reason to take offense at it?

It doesn't bother me that Italians call me an americano instead of an American. It's just a letter change. So why is it so bothersome that it's called Farsi rather than Parsi? Can't the change from "p" to "f" be seen as an interesting historical quirk, due to the fascinating effect of Arabic on European languages in the Middle Ages? At the same time that we got Arabic words like "algebra" and "alcohol"?

Re: NotebookLM Audio Overviews are now available in over 50 languages

#49
I really don't understand why they went with this podcast style. Sure, it makes an impression the first few times, great for a showcase or an announcement. The problem though is that it soon becomes pretty annoying, especially because the hosts go back and forth between knowing nothing and knowing everything about the topic. They should at least choose randomly which one does the explaining to whom.

Re: NotebookLM Audio Overviews are now available in over 50 languages

#50

I really don't understand why they went with this podcast style. Sure, it makes an impression the first few times, great for a showcase or an announcement. The problem though is that it soon becomes pretty annoying, especially because the hosts go back and forth between knowing nothing and knowing everything about the topic. They should at least choose randomly which one does the explaining to whom.

Absolutely agree with you, we ran into the same issue. Our company actually tried using it for our software documentation and user onboarding, hoping it would be a helpful and engaging format. But the podcast-style delivery just didn’t fit our needs. It’s fine for a quick showcase or intro, but for ongoing support or business-oriented material, the format became distracting. If only they offered alternative styles—something more structured and professional—we might have stuck with it.
Post reply on HN