Live data from Hacker News

The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance Is a Stone-Cold Masterpiece

gizmodo.com

41–50 of 119 posts

Re: The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance Is a Stone-Cold Masterpiece

#42
post #33
post #17

This was a brilliant show, but it had the misfortune to come along at a time when Netflix was cancelling even moderate successes after one season and slashing the budget of hit shows for their second season before cancelling them too (e.g. Altered Carbon). Only very rarely does a show turn into the kind of pop culture sensation that seems to make the bean-counters want to go past two seasons (e.g. Stranger Things), u…

Yeah I was upset at Altered Carbon being cancelled. It was very good. I've been hoping a video game studio picks up the rights and makes a good AA or AAA game. I sadly didn't find Altered Carbon: Resleeved as good as the main series.

IMO only the first season was really good, while the second one was very bad, I almost wish they had cancelled it after the first instead.

Re: The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance Is a Stone-Cold Masterpiece

#43
post #42
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah I was upset at Altered Carbon being cancelled. It was very good. I've been hoping a video game studio picks up the rights and makes a good AA or AAA game. I sadly didn't find Altered Carbon: Resleeved as good as the main series.

IMO only the first season was really good, while the second one was very bad, I almost wish they had cancelled it after the first instead.

I didn't find it bad, but it was different, I think the show was trying to find a new direction to make the series last, which obviously didn't work.

Re: The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance Is a Stone-Cold Masterpiece

#45
I loved DC:AoR but I never expected it was anything more than a one-off. Keep following the struggle as much as you like, but you still know that in the end, the Gelflings lose. I mean yes they pull it off in the end and maybe the Ur-Skeks magic them all back, they discover a lost tribe, whatever, but in the meantime they pretty much get wiped out. Making a good story in the face of that dark inevitability is what the writing craft is about, and they pulled it off and left on a high note. Best thing they can do is leave it that way.

Re: The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance Is a Stone-Cold Masterpiece

#46
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Very common in eastern storytelling. Ghibli films are some of my favorite for many reasons, but I particularly love how they contrast ideas.

I think Studio Ghibli's 'secret sauce' is the "Kishōtenketsu" or four act structure that makes Studio Ghibli special: 1. Ki (Introduction) - Sets up characters and situation. 2. Shō (Development) - Expands the characters and fleshes them out. 3. Ten (Twist) - Introduces a new element or change. 4. Ketsu (Conclusion) - Shows the outcome and connections between elements. In contrast Western films usually follow a three…

They look like the same steps to me, with steps 1 and 2 both being Setup. The dramatic arc is fairly universal, and Miyazaki is hardly an exotic unfamiliar with western culture.

Re: The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance Is a Stone-Cold Masterpiece

#47
post #31
post #19

How strange, the most positive review I heard from anyone I know was that "It ruined my childhood" and that it let's say "craped" on the source material. Mind you these are the nicest things people said. I have not seen it nor the original film to be fair, but this is quite literally the first positive thing I have heard about it.

If you're a sci-fi and/or a fantasy fan I really recommend watching the original film and the prequel in that order and make your own mind up. I was young when the original came out so I found it good but scary. I felt the prequel was excellent and it left me wanting more. These days I feel a lot of my youthful nostalgia has been vandalised for a quick corporate buck. Probably the worst has been Willow on Disney+. Th…

What happened to Willow?

Re: The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance Is a Stone-Cold Masterpiece

#48
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Very common in eastern storytelling. Ghibli films are some of my favorite for many reasons, but I particularly love how they contrast ideas.

I think Studio Ghibli's 'secret sauce' is the "Kishōtenketsu" or four act structure that makes Studio Ghibli special: 1. Ki (Introduction) - Sets up characters and situation. 2. Shō (Development) - Expands the characters and fleshes them out. 3. Ten (Twist) - Introduces a new element or change. 4. Ketsu (Conclusion) - Shows the outcome and connections between elements. In contrast Western films usually follow a three…

Miyazaki stated that he was trying to break everything he knows about story structure with Mononoke. Last time I saw it, it became clear to me that it’s almost impossible to fit into any story structure and it’s just one giant crescendo to the end. More like a minimalist music piece than anything.

Re: The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance Is a Stone-Cold Masterpiece

#49
The writing in the series is unfortunately terrible. It sinks the otherwise beautiful show with sterile and laborious narration/dialogue, telltale signs of over workshopped writing room slop, from which no real living plot ever emerges. Such a disappointment.

Re: The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance Is a Stone-Cold Masterpiece

#50
The author seems to conflate "dark" with "adult", so let me take the chance to point out this common mistake. Horror films, Warhammer 40K and 2000 AD comics are all famously dark, but they're for kids or teens. A Midsummer Night's Dream and The Importance of Being Earnest are light but grown-up. It's a weird deformation of the past generation to think that being depressing makes you deep.
Post reply on HN