Live data from Hacker News

Do Lake Names Reflect Their Properties?

ivanludvig.dev

41–45 of 45 posts

Re: Do Lake Names Reflect Their Properties?

#41
post #29

Some lakes undergo drastic changes through the seasons. I know of a few that go from dark blue(late fall, early spring) to brown(spring runoff sediment) to dark green(algae in summer) in a single year.

The three lakes of Kelimutu in Indonesia are famous for changing color on a multi-year cycle.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelimutu

Re: Do Lake Names Reflect Their Properties?

#42

Obviously this is just for fun, but I am a bit disturbed about similar projects that try to gain some meaningful insights out of vast public data sets without the slightest attention paid to the quality of the data used. It doesn’t matter how much processing you do or how clever your algorithms are if the underlaying data is inaccurate, out of date, inconsistent, non-normalized, incomplete, etc. No dataset is perfect…

> I am a bit disturbed about similar projects that try to gain some meaningful insights out of vast public data sets without the slightest attention paid to the quality of the data used.

Indeed, this story is a very good example of that in the academic world (Economics): https://nitter.poast.org/andreloez/status/181747110580160124...

Re: Do Lake Names Reflect Their Properties?

#43
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah I stopped taking this post seriously when I read this sentence: > I fetched the satellite image tile for the zoomed-in region of each lake center and read a single pixel at the center of the tile, which should give us an idea of the lake’s color

Well, I mean, it's an idea.

It’s a model, it might not be perfect, but you also need to decide how much scientific rigor and effort you want to invest in this problem.

To be honest, just picking a random pixel would have been fine, too, anything else is an overkill.

Re: Do Lake Names Reflect Their Properties?

#44

Well, here in Massachusetts we have Lake Char­gogg­a­gogg­man­chaugg­a­gogg­chau­bun­a­gung­a­maugg, which doesn't describe its color but does mean "lake divided by islands" and is a pretty accurate, if long winded, description of it.

Growing up I was told it actually meant something like "you fish over there, I fish over here, nobody fishes in the middle" and that is was some sort of territory boundary.
Post reply on HN