Live data from Hacker News

Installing Arch Linux on a Laptop

giacomo.coletto.io

41–50 of 139 posts

Re: Installing Arch Linux on a Laptop

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I actually agree that the Arch docs are absolutely excellent in their level of detail, precision and helpfulness. I also think its possible for them to simultaneously be a gate keeping mechanism and stand by what I said

well if you stand by them, do you plan to present actual evidence of the alleged conspiracy or are you just making these statements to troll?

[deleted]

Re: Installing Arch Linux on a Laptop

#43

These types of posts are often more harfmul than helpful. ArchLinux already has proper installation instructions and those who cannot follow them aren't recommend to run it. The main installation issues the ArchLinux forum sees is from people following outdated third party installation guides.

Just as an example, this guide suddenly assumes that "yay" is installed. Even though AUR helpers like yay aren't officially recommended by ArchLinux and also aren't trivial to install.

The design decisions around AUR befuddle me to this day. It's utterly arcane in how to use it. Or rather it feels like it wasn't designed at all and simply evolved.

I highly recommend people to use "yay" and similar helpers that make a lot of the problems simply go away.

Re: Installing Arch Linux on a Laptop

#46
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

these days I ask chatgpt for help to install arch instead of using the docs which are designed as a gate keeping mechanism to discourage the uninitiated by making them feel stupid. chatgpt just tells you how to do and turns out its really not that hard.

I really think that's unfair. The install docs are quite long but they try to give people options. It's not gate keeping to provide a lot of detail.

The install wiki is full of outdated information that causes people to install outdated and old methods of doing things. So I wouldn't advise people to use it, other than the fact there's no other option.

Re: Installing Arch Linux on a Laptop

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I actually agree that the Arch docs are absolutely excellent in their level of detail, precision and helpfulness. I also think its possible for them to simultaneously be a gate keeping mechanism and stand by what I said

well if you stand by them, do you plan to present actual evidence of the alleged conspiracy or are you just making these statements to troll?

isn’t gatekeeping inherently subjective? it’s going to be hard to present objective evidence to a subjective expression of opinion.

Re: Installing Arch Linux on a Laptop

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

well if you stand by them, do you plan to present actual evidence of the alleged conspiracy or are you just making these statements to troll?

isn’t gatekeeping inherently subjective? it’s going to be hard to present objective evidence to a subjective expression of opinion.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN