Live data from Hacker News

I asked ChatGPT to summarize 14501 books in 5 bullet points. Here's the result

bookpecker.com

41–50 of 54 posts

Re: I asked ChatGPT to summarize 14501 books in 5 bullet points. Here's the result

#41

Is it actually summarizing the books, or is it regurgitating things other people have said about the books in its training data?

Since no one is born with innate understanding of what "summarize a book" means, the same question can be raised about people.

Re: I asked ChatGPT to summarize 14501 books in 5 bullet points. Here's the result

#42
Those are numbered points, not bullet points.

Did you actually ask for bullet points and ChatGPT gave you numbered points instead? Or did you just ask for 5 point summaries and it chose to use numbered points?

For the books I checked where I felt I could reasonably guess what topics would be covered and in what order, the 5 points seemed to cover things in the same order I expect the book covered them.

If that is the case numbered points would be more appropriate than bullet points, so if it was ChatGPT that decided on numbers vs. bullets it looks like it made the right call.

Re: I asked ChatGPT to summarize 14501 books in 5 bullet points. Here's the result

#44

It looks like a lot of these are self-help or other fluffy books. It's funny because whenever I read these books I feel like someone just took a bunch of bullet points and then added anecdotes and fluff to make it fill a book. Herd you're reversing the process.

This is my feeling two. Many times the author tries to say the same thing 20 different times to fill a book. Many ot those books could have been a great 30 minute presentation.

  > Many times the author tries to say the same thing 20 different times to fill a book. Many of those books could have been a great 30 minute presentation.
This is indeed how many, many of these books started -- as a $x minute presentation or an article.

I always try to find the source presentation or article and consume that before reading a book. It has served me well. You get the core ideas, concisely, without the fluff.

Re: I asked ChatGPT to summarize 14501 books in 5 bullet points. Here's the result

#50

It looks like a lot of these are self-help or other fluffy books. It's funny because whenever I read these books I feel like someone just took a bunch of bullet points and then added anecdotes and fluff to make it fill a book. Herd you're reversing the process.

If you're into savage debunking of junk self-help books, check out Michael Hobbs and Peter Shamshiri's podcast _If Books Could Kill_. Their obliteration of _Rich Dad, Poor Dad_ (the first book highlighted on this site) is one of their best episodes.
Post reply on HN