Live data from Hacker News

46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

nathanbransford.com

41–50 of 181 posts

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because most of the great intellectual works exist in these "legacy form factors."

Of the past yes, but what about the present and future?

Well, can you name a computer game that is a great artistic work? There are many that are good, but I can't say there are any that are on a par with, say, "The Lord of the Rings" or "War and Peace" or "1984".

I'd love to hear of one that was though.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#43

But all my friends on Goodreads are claiming to finish a book a week Are... Are they LYING?? No one lies on the internet. EDIT: Wow I guess I hit a, nerve. Sorry folks. I use Goodreads and finish about a book a month. So I don't think a book a week is unreasonable/impossible. I just meant to allude to the fact that the platform has gotten a lot of attention for review bombing and profile manipulation. Anyways, here i…

There was span of a couple years when I had to commute ~3 hours per day. I easily completed 1-2 audiobooks per week.

But more to your point, what percentage of the population do you think is active on goodreads? I can't find any MAU numbers for them, just total membership numbers. Regardless, it is a self-selecting audience. Much like if you go to a theater to see the latest garbage marvel movie, the people in that theater are probably very likely to have seen other marvel movies in the theater recently too.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#44

But all my friends on Goodreads are claiming to finish a book a week Are... Are they LYING?? No one lies on the internet. EDIT: Wow I guess I hit a, nerve. Sorry folks. I use Goodreads and finish about a book a month. So I don't think a book a week is unreasonable/impossible. I just meant to allude to the fact that the platform has gotten a lot of attention for review bombing and profile manipulation. Anyways, here i…

I finish about a book a week, reading a couple of hours a night before sleep. It's not unreasonable.

I’m all for reading, but a couple of hours every night is a very big time investment.

People with children are often lucky to have 30 minutes for themselves.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#46
post #8

Why do we obsess so much over legacy form factors? Watching movies, listening to 2h conference talks, playing a 60h narrative videogame, and reading scientific papers in PDF may not be as noble, but they are equally meaningful to me.

Reading is an active skill vs watching something is more passive. There’s lots of pathways in your brain that intensive reading lights up compared to other mediums. And lots of studies show that you retain more information and building stronger informational connections when reading vs watching.

No one is telling you to stop watching movies or playing video games, but being a more active participant in a leisure activity can be beneficial every once in a while.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#47

And worst than that, I wonder about the quality of the books for the other 54%. Reading a book by itself is not a virtue.

Agree. I have a friend who, to put it kindly, is more brawn than brain.

Voracious reader. Dozens of books a year, all swords & sorcery. Not really anything he could learn from.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#48
Not an American.

I read a lot but I can't think of a book I read last year.

I don't think "didn't read a book" is that useful for inference about imagination, literacy, education etc., unless it's also matched by watching an enormous amount of linear or episodic television.

"Didn't read a book" might, however, be a meaningful proxy for shorter attention spans. I think it could be in my case, even though I read voraciously.

Re: 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023

#50

And worst than that, I wonder about the quality of the books for the other 54%. Reading a book by itself is not a virtue.

As someone who listens to a _lot_ of audio books, I'll admit that the majority of them are quite entertaining but are definitely not worth vaunting over other forms of entertainment. Most of the more intellectually demanding reading I do tends to not even come from books, but rather from things like academic papers, blog posts, and long form articles.
Post reply on HN