Live data from Hacker News

Lessons from history's greatest R&D labs

answer.ai

41–50 of 56 posts

Re: Lessons from history's greatest R&D labs

#41

The name is bad and the name is everything in tech. I thought it was some answers.com AI spinoff. This is far too generic and a google search of it is a nightmare. You don't buy your books on books.com, you buy them on amazon.com, you don't buy your pet supplies on pets.com, you buy them on chewy.com.

pets.com is owned and redirected to PetSmart, sort of proves your point but sort of not.

Re: Lessons from history's greatest R&D labs

#42
Eric's depiction of Edison and his rapid experimentation sounds very similar to the descriptions of one of Edison's contemporaries, Luther Burbank, as told in The Garden of Invention by Jane S. Smith. I recommend this book to the author (if he hasn't already read it himself) as I do to anybody else who enjoyed his essay.

There's a lot to be said for just exploring the combinatorial space of possibility in even a naive or brute force manner.

Re: Lessons from history's greatest R&D labs

#43

This makes me nostalgic for something that I never had and doesn't seem to exist anymore, labs unburdened by either the red tape of government or academia, or alternately, the pressure for results and profits that many startups seem to slaved to. Is there a 21st century equivalent of Bell Labs out there somewhere? Asking for a friend.

I believe Microsoft Research is the closest thing to the old Bell Labs or the old Xerox PARC that exists today, but I’ve heard that even MSR has changed (though this is just hearsay). I’ve heard historically researchers at MSR had a wide degree of freedom, and there has been many interesting projects coming out of there, my favorites being Singularity and Midori. Once again I don’t know how free the lab culture is, and I also don’t know the lab’s performance review criteria.

https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/

Re: Lessons from history's greatest R&D labs

#44
post #20
post #18

What service was used to create the Ai voice? It's one of the first I've heard that sounds pleasant and life like.

I believe it was done with OpenAI TTS

Yup, I just used the default demo of their TTS to convert the article one chunk at a time so I could listen while I swapped some RAM around. https://platform.openai.com/docs/guides/text-to-speech

Re: Lessons from history's greatest R&D labs

#45

> Legally, Answer.AI is a company. But in practice, it might hover somewhere between a lab and a normal “profit-maximizing firm” — as was the case with Edison’s lab. The founders seem perfectly content to pursue high-risk projects that might lead to failures or lack of revenue for quite a while. In saying this, I do not mean to imply they are content to light money on fire doing research with no chance of a return. R…

One benefit answer.ai has over some of those labs is that it's building software, so expenses are mostly just salaries and GPU time - no need for massive capex on fabrication equipment or anything like that. And since we're focused on efficient fine-tuning and inference rather than foundation model training, even the GPU spend is likely to be extremely modest compared to some other players :)

Re: Lessons from history's greatest R&D labs

#46
post #3

Jeremy from Answer.AI here -- Answer.AI is, to some extent, the subject of this article. Perhaps worth noting here that we didn't pay the author, Eric Gilliam; it's his independent analysis based on years of study of 19th & 20th century R&D labs. I'm hoping that not only will Answer.AI be successful, but that Eric's words in the conclusion will come to pass: > "If their USD10 million experiment works, it has the chan…

Would you consider providing an RSS feed for the list of published articles? Thank you.

Re: Lessons from history's greatest R&D labs

#47
post #3

Jeremy from Answer.AI here -- Answer.AI is, to some extent, the subject of this article. Perhaps worth noting here that we didn't pay the author, Eric Gilliam; it's his independent analysis based on years of study of 19th & 20th century R&D labs. I'm hoping that not only will Answer.AI be successful, but that Eric's words in the conclusion will come to pass: > "If their USD10 million experiment works, it has the chan…

Would you consider providing an RSS feed for the list of published articles? Thank you.

Oh good point - I forgot to set that up!

Re: Lessons from history's greatest R&D labs

#48

This makes me nostalgic for something that I never had and doesn't seem to exist anymore, labs unburdened by either the red tape of government or academia, or alternately, the pressure for results and profits that many startups seem to slaved to. Is there a 21st century equivalent of Bell Labs out there somewhere? Asking for a friend.

I’ve been reading lots of history books and interesting narratives. It seems like some sort of result-oriented pressure or a resource-based constraint has nearly always been the case with R&D and inventions. If Bell Labs is about laid back experimentation, I guess it’s more of an exception that proves the rule in these things. Even Google tends to feel the pressure of interest rates going up and lots of the more laid back stuff being thrown off as ”zero interest rate phenomenon” moonshot bets.

Re: Lessons from history's greatest R&D labs

#49
post #3

Jeremy from Answer.AI here -- Answer.AI is, to some extent, the subject of this article. Perhaps worth noting here that we didn't pay the author, Eric Gilliam; it's his independent analysis based on years of study of 19th & 20th century R&D labs. I'm hoping that not only will Answer.AI be successful, but that Eric's words in the conclusion will come to pass: > "If their USD10 million experiment works, it has the chan…

I like the very idea of applying this transformative AI technology to make values. I have been doing research and always been a member of research team ever since I started the ML journey. But, I've always valued applications that can solve problems and found myself inclined to building apps. I would love to work at Answer.AI. How can I apply?

Re: Lessons from history's greatest R&D labs

#50
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How are you thinking about the role of patenting at Answer.AI? How about handling tech transfer issues with universities?

I don't think we'll want to patent anything, since that's something which keeps people out -- and we want to let people in! The only reason I could think of that we'd need a patent portfolio would be for defensive purposes.

That's different from how things worked for Edison. But similar to how they worked for Luther Burbank.

I'll be rooting for you to succeed in this endeavor. I used to visit IBM ARC when I was a kid, and to my mind the academic environment is not quite the same. But as you know we really have not seen corporate R and D recover from the peaks it attained over fifty years ago.

Post reply on HN