Live data from Hacker News

Reasons medieval people slept in cupboards

bbc.com

41–50 of 95 posts

Re: Reasons medieval people slept in cupboards

#41
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you trying to stop sound getting in or getting out? In the first case some decent earplugs should be sufficient.

No, they are not. Imagine some construction work with heavy drilling outside your bedroom window.

In this case, it's not just sound vibrations but vibrations that you can feel in your house and bed! Truly difficult. Double or staggered stud walls really help.

Re: Reasons medieval people slept in cupboards

#42

It's bad because you are isolated. You need to get grounded in order to sleep properly: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15650465/ Big fluffy beds way off the floor are bad. It's interesting to note that the above finds it most effective for women. The below is most effective for men. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10105021/ It shouldn't actually matter your sex. To add, buddhist monks must sleep on the…

is it just me or does that second link resemble pseudoscience?

"Earthing" is definitely in the pseudoscience category. There's no supposed mechanism, and "earth" is just a relative point anyway.

Re: Reasons medieval people slept in cupboards

#43
For me, one important bit is missing.

> Alcoves were hygienically problematic, as the straw was sometimes only rarely changed, ventilation was poor and food supplies were often stored under the alcoves in farmhouses. To combat tuberculosis, the Baupolizei [government institution in germany responsible for building codes] took action against alcoves from the end of the 19th century. In the Free State of Oldenburg, the health insurance companies paid 100 Reichsmark per removed alcove in 1926.

Source: https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alkoven_(Bettnische)

I would assume that in other european countries the situation was similar.

Re: Reasons medieval people slept in cupboards

#44
post #35

Make it soundproof and take my money.

Are you trying to stop sound getting in or getting out? In the first case some decent earplugs should be sufficient.

Nathan for You S3.E6 also explored this idea as a hotel amenity for sexually active parents.

Re: Reasons medieval people slept in cupboards

#45
post #10

When I was young and had a bunk bed it was pretty normal to box the lower bunk in with sheets, cushions from the couch — whatever — just to make it into a cave-like thing. Suddenly I want something like this again.

We called that, among other things, "making a fort." Do today's helicopter kids not do that?

Turns out that air power renders fortifications obsolete.

Re: Reasons medieval people slept in cupboards

#46
One of the most memorable sleeps I've had is sleeping on the middle shelf of a closet in northern Japan during winter in a poorly-insulated house with minimal heat. I left the sliding door open a crack, snuggled into my sleeping bag under extra blankets, and slept about ten hours.

Re: Reasons medieval people slept in cupboards

#47
post #39
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's most likely false, considering the rate of malnourishment before the Industrial and Agricultural Revolutions.

There’s some nuance/caveats, but here’s a study showing humans lost height during the switch from hunting/gathering to agriculture: https://modernfarmer.com/2022/04/farming-made-our-ancestors-...

And, though I'm sure there are going to be objections, in both time periods people would be considered nutritionally deficient when compared to today.

Re: Reasons medieval people slept in cupboards

#48
We often forget just how revolutionary proper insulation and central heating really is. For example in many climates castles were not great places to live in. You simply can't heat that amount of stone and space effectively. And similar thing also went to most buildings.

Re: Reasons medieval people slept in cupboards

#49
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some issue with bringing this design into today: - air quality (especially if closed off), less air volume means the air gets bad faster - air humidity, raises faster through sweat in a cupboard setup, for the same reason the inner tent of good tents tends to be made of a fabric which allows air humidity to go out of the inner tent (I think, haven't bought a tent forever) - fungus mainly due to the higher humidity/re…

A good ducted ERV could solve all those problems

In the end we're going to end up with something something that's the mix between a coffin and a computer case. Fan noise would be a big issue.

Re: Reasons medieval people slept in cupboards

#50
post #12

I would love this. I've never understood why humans waste square footage on large bedrooms. Seriously, I could sleep in a closet and be perfectly happy.

Some issue with bringing this design into today: - air quality (especially if closed off), less air volume means the air gets bad faster - air humidity, raises faster through sweat in a cupboard setup, for the same reason the inner tent of good tents tends to be made of a fabric which allows air humidity to go out of the inner tent (I think, haven't bought a tent forever) - fungus mainly due to the higher humidity/re…

At the same time, for small volume, it’s much easier to condition and monitor the air to exactly how you want it.
Post reply on HN