Live data from Hacker News

YouTube Begins Blocking Users Who Use Adblock

support.google.com

41–50 of 116 posts

Re: YouTube Begins Blocking Users Who Use Adblock

#41
post #18
post #10

I feel like I'm in the minority that has zero problem paying for an ad-free experience. I get tremendous value out of YouTube in both professional and personal ways. I have a daughter who watches it often. Suppressing ads while supporting the service my family enjoys regularly seems like a no-brainer to me. And I never have to worry about them circumventing my ad blocker.

Yeah but I have a problem with being bullied into paying them. It will just make me want to make their engineers life a pain by working on work-arounds.

We got some different definitions of being bullied. I run pi-hole, ublock, sponsorblock but also pay for yt premium.

Re: YouTube Begins Blocking Users Who Use Adblock

#42
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know how it is done for certain, but with absolute control of the client you could send any information back to Youtube that you wanted. So if all Youtube was requesting was that the minimal amount of time of ads be watched before playing the video you just tell them that you have. I'm sure it is getting far more complicated than this, but I suspect this is the basic idea of this back and forth arms race of a…

If YouTube wants full control over the ads experience, they will have to splice the ad into the video stream itself, and block seeking requests until: 1. The entirety of the ad portion of the video stream has been successfully sent to the client 2. A length of time equivalent to the ad duration has passed A sufficiently advanced ad blocker would be able to block the ad, but you would still be forced to sit through se…

This is known as SSAI for server side ad insertion.

Re: YouTube Begins Blocking Users Who Use Adblock

#43

This marks the moment Google officially decided it didn’t know how to innovate any longer, and that it’s time to grab all they can to increase the bottom line. Most technology companies follow this same cycle. When they’re in the innovation/disruption phase, there are less rules, they just focus on giving people the best experience. When they start stagnating, suddenly every cent matters. The irony is that the profil…

> This marks the moment Google officially decided it didn’t know how to innovate any longer

What? THIS marks that moment? I haven't seen google innovate since they built google search. Literally every other successful thing they have was bought.

Re: YouTube Begins Blocking Users Who Use Adblock

#45
post #10

I feel like I'm in the minority that has zero problem paying for an ad-free experience. I get tremendous value out of YouTube in both professional and personal ways. I have a daughter who watches it often. Suppressing ads while supporting the service my family enjoys regularly seems like a no-brainer to me. And I never have to worry about them circumventing my ad blocker.

I've posted this a few times recently, but I used to pay for youtube premium, but it started showing me ads while using chromecast. The third time it happened I cancelled and went back to using ublock. I don't use the chromecast much because the ads are unbearable but I see exactly 0 ads ever on my pc. In short, I block ads because not only is it free, it also actually works. My guess is as soon as(if?) they manage t…

Yeah, if I start seeing ads on anything while signed into my active Premium account, I'm going to start asking questions or considering other options as well. Hoping it doesn't come down to that.

Re: YouTube Begins Blocking Users Who Use Adblock

#46

I have such mixed feelings about this. I can't stand to waste the time on ads so I started using an alternative client that doesn't have any ads. However, I do recognize that I've been using youtube for 15+ years without paying a cent or watching any ads - which is pretty unreasonable. No streaming service or television channel has ever been free with no ads. I can't really justify it. And yet, I'm not willing to pay…

i would buy for 5 a month for ad-free, but newpipe + revanced is better on mobile and on desktop kodi, or SmartTubeNext

i don't want to pay for a worst experience.

Re: YouTube Begins Blocking Users Who Use Adblock

#47
post #10

I feel like I'm in the minority that has zero problem paying for an ad-free experience. I get tremendous value out of YouTube in both professional and personal ways. I have a daughter who watches it often. Suppressing ads while supporting the service my family enjoys regularly seems like a no-brainer to me. And I never have to worry about them circumventing my ad blocker.

I'm probably also in the minority, but I think Youtube having a near monopoly in this space is bad for consumers and would prefer to see some alternatives. If by merely executing control over my own hardware to see only what I want is enough to actively harm them then so be it. I also have been subscribed to NebulaTV and Curiosity Stream for years.

Same. And I support several of my favorite creators on Patreon and Ko-fi. And I try to watch their videos on Nebula. If I could find any of them on PeerTube I'd do that instead.

Unfortunately it feels like spitting into a hurricane. I can say I'm fighting the good fight, but am I making a difference? I doubt it, I doubt it very much.

Re: YouTube Begins Blocking Users Who Use Adblock

#48

This marks the moment Google officially decided it didn’t know how to innovate any longer, and that it’s time to grab all they can to increase the bottom line. Most technology companies follow this same cycle. When they’re in the innovation/disruption phase, there are less rules, they just focus on giving people the best experience. When they start stagnating, suddenly every cent matters. The irony is that the profil…

The silicon valley engineer should also be able to easily afford premium.

Re: YouTube Begins Blocking Users Who Use Adblock

#50

I have such mixed feelings about this. I can't stand to waste the time on ads so I started using an alternative client that doesn't have any ads. However, I do recognize that I've been using youtube for 15+ years without paying a cent or watching any ads - which is pretty unreasonable. No streaming service or television channel has ever been free with no ads. I can't really justify it. And yet, I'm not willing to pay…

> without paying a cent

You mean, YouTube has not paid you a cent for your attention.

Post reply on HN