Live data from Hacker News

Tesla is launching their developer APIs

developer.tesla.com

41–50 of 131 posts

Re: Tesla is launching their developer APIs

#41
post #16

Given the state of the Twitter API post-Elon, I'd be incredibly unlikely to rely on this unless I have a business contract directly with Tesla with appropriate penalties if my app / access were to be revoked.

Cool.

There's probably 10,000s of devs who think otherwise, tho.

Re: Tesla is launching their developer APIs

#42

If you are wondering about the state of auto API's here's a partial list of loads of makes and models that have some form of over the air endpoints via a 3rd party: https://connectyourcar.com/compatibility/makes/

that isn't a list of cars that support anything "via 3rd party" or have APIs. these are mostly cars with first party over the air apps.

Re: Tesla is launching their developer APIs

#44
post #16

Given the state of the Twitter API post-Elon, I'd be incredibly unlikely to rely on this unless I have a business contract directly with Tesla with appropriate penalties if my app / access were to be revoked.

Twitter is more alive, vibrant and honest than ever, so this seems like a strange comparison.

Re: Tesla is launching their developer APIs

#45
I take it as a sign of the current state of hackernews that nearly no one took the time to actually RTFA. This isnt about making apps that run on the car, this is about being able to integrate your external apps with the fleet API. Like, can external app that has permission would be able to locate the vehicle.

That said, I think the security implications are fairly important, since I expect one of the exposed features is to be able to unlock or start the car.

Re: Tesla is launching their developer APIs

#46

I'm calling for Tesla to open source all the code running onboard it's vehicles. Consumers have the right to understand how their machines work. Elon, you built an empire off the backs of open source developers. Give back.

Tesla violated the GPL in the past https://techworm.net/programming/tesla-disclosed-autopilot-s...

Are they in compliance with the GPL now?

Re: Tesla is launching their developer APIs

#47

I'm calling for Tesla to open source all the code running onboard it's vehicles. Consumers have the right to understand how their machines work. Elon, you built an empire off the backs of open source developers. Give back.

What about all of the other cars' code that massively outnumber Teslas? Why not also call for theirs too?

Re: Tesla is launching their developer APIs

#48

I'm calling for Tesla to open source all the code running onboard it's vehicles. Consumers have the right to understand how their machines work. Elon, you built an empire off the backs of open source developers. Give back.

Elon is not against open sourcing more code: https://techcrunch.com/2023/05/25/elon-musk-says-tesla-might... > Consumers have the right to understand how their machines work Windows and macOS aren't open source either and the vast majority of consumers don't care. It would be cool to be able to install an open source third party OS on your car though...

What Elon says, and what Elon actually thinks are two different non-intersecting sets. As evidenced by his actions

Re: Tesla is launching their developer APIs

#49
post #16

Given the state of the Twitter API post-Elon, I'd be incredibly unlikely to rely on this unless I have a business contract directly with Tesla with appropriate penalties if my app / access were to be revoked.

Tesla Engineering has their shit together, Elon is very detached from their work. Comparing Tesla to Twitter is not reasonable

Their shit is apart, and it's rather unbecoming of a tech company and a car manufacturer. It's supposed to be the opposite of that.

Re: Tesla is launching their developer APIs

#50
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tesla Engineering has their shit together, Elon is very detached from their work. Comparing Tesla to Twitter is not reasonable

My own anecdotal contribution, based off the constant bickering of people I know who work for engineering firms that have Tesla as a client, is that they do not have any of their shit organized in a manner which could be remotely described as "together".

There are many words I could use to describe my limited interactions with Tesla manufacturing, but "together" is not one of them.

After being harried to hurry up and build something exactly to the 34th revision of their ever-changing specs (the inside of the electrical panel was powder-coated the wrong manufacturer-original color and therefore unacceptable, and on and on...) and warned about the severe penalties for late delivery and downtime, we got it all finished only to find that they weren't actually ready for it yet. The production floor where it was supposed to go has no room, they haven't gotten permits to even start to pour concrete where it's going to go later...

The one good thing I can say is that at least they paid on time, even though they didn't take delivery yet - better than a lot of "net 30...months" OEMs out there.

Post reply on HN