Live data from Hacker News

Redmine – open-source project management

redmine.org

41–50 of 83 posts

Re: Redmine – open-source project management

#41
I introduced Redmine at my last job and it was great. I heard one dev say 'we would never have launched without it'.

My biggest memory of Redmine is that EVERY time I thought, 'I wish it could do x', I clicked around and found it could.

I installed it in 1 click from an Azure template too.

Re: Redmine – open-source project management

#42
I work at a small-to-medium sized ISP, and we use pure Redmine since 2018 for documentation, and 'internal tickets'. It's a really good tool, helped us get really organized. You can customize the heck out of it, nowadays we have really complex BIs to monitor tickt times, SLAs, project activity, etc. The API is very good and i made a ton of usefull things with it, even Telegram bots for our internal groups.

The biggest complaint we have on it is how bad it's wiki search features are, and indeed they are too simple.

Re: Redmine – open-source project management

#43
The last shop I worked at used Redmine. The owner loved it, most folks found it okay, but the UX just rubbed me the wrong way. I'm not opposed to working with software with classic UIs and such, that would have been fine if the update workflow and page layout made sense.

I wish I could adequately convey why. Based on other commenters talking about the APIs being strong though, and other products that seem nicer (I tried OpenProject for a time and had a pretty positive experience with it) are built upon it, it really goes to show how much a good UX can make or break a project with really great bones.

Re: Redmine – open-source project management

#44
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The company I work for switched from redmine to jira few years ago, after using redmine since 2009 or so. It was a really bad decision spearheaded by a single project manager. I miss redmine. I hate having to see the constant interstitial loading animation in Jira. And working through small modals. Just load the damn page for the link I clicked on. All the “single page application” junk is rarely executed well. But I…

You’re not a dinosaur for hating the continued consumerization of products and services targeted toward use cases that are expert in nature. Sure, have a simpler GUI for Jira Service Desk users in a non-technical customer service role. Give me a different GUI that’s not driven by designers looking to reinvent. I don’t need that, I don’t want that, and it just wastes my time.

It sounds like you might have a permissions issue. You can route issues created from Jira Service Desk to any board you want.

Re: Redmine – open-source project management

#45
post #3

I am shocked to see the design did not change a bit.

Likewise. I used it 10 years ago and it looks the same. Good luck trying to get non-technical people to use it.

Non-tech people can use it with no issues, my whole company uses it. People just need to pay attention to what they are doing, and be organized. At the beginning it can be kinda painfull, but it's all worth it.

Re: Redmine – open-source project management

#46

The last shop I worked at used Redmine. The owner loved it, most folks found it okay, but the UX just rubbed me the wrong way. I'm not opposed to working with software with classic UIs and such, that would have been fine if the update workflow and page layout made sense. I wish I could adequately convey why. Based on other commenters talking about the APIs being strong though, and other products that seem nicer (I tr…

Redmine might look clunky from a distance, and its installation is convoluted. However, once it works, it works forever.

It's a "zero unplanned maintenance" tool which works without any problems, and can be extended with tons of features due to its extensible nature.

Maybe it's about being an oldish folk who used "classical UI"s more, yet I still find their information density much better than modern "fluffy and animated" UIs. No JS animations to waste power, no browser version requirement, just a brutalist structure built around function.

Paired with a powerful VM, it loads instantly, works perfectly.

Re: Redmine – open-source project management

#47
I wish I was still on Redmine. The interface turned off the "boss", but I've been a refugee in attempting to solve his UI issues through Wrike, Trello, ClickUp and more.

I was never more productive as an IT Manager than with Redmine. It's so fast to get things entered and added, which was a boon for us. I miss it.

Re: Redmine – open-source project management

#49

I’ve been using redmine for a decade for creating a project task breakdown, tracking time on tasks and projects and using that data to invoice customers, as well as issue tracking. The interface works, I don’t mind it. It allows export of data easily, and pdf generation. I wish redmine’s website for showing users what plugins exist and are up to date was a bit better. Plug-ins always seem to fall in to disrepair, and…

Wow, through Docker? How please? And Still with APIs?

Re: Redmine – open-source project management

#50
post #8

Redmine is great. Serves us without issues since 2007. I honestly don't understand companies using products like Jira when Redmine is available.

I'm currently using GitHub Projects for the Kannan view that integrates with Issues. Does Redmine have that feature?

There's a lot of paid plugins that throw a new interface on it but no, base redmine doesn't have a click and drag kanban. It does have all kinds of project management integrated with git tickets, I thought the gantt chart was perfectly good tho.
Post reply on HN