Live data from Hacker News

Human Or Not: Guess if you're chatting with an AI or a Human

app.humanornot.ai

41–50 of 62 posts

Re: Human Or Not: Guess if you're chatting with an AI or a Human

#45

"something" went wrong? why lie and pretend you are surprised by what happened? it's your censorship filter going haywire, just admit it

This is unfairly downvoted. The site bans people who use rude words (I tested the n-word and the r-word). This is bad because the ability to use slurs is a fundamental difference between humans and AIs, which are trained to avoid inappropriate language. If the point of the game is to suss out the difference between AIs and humans, you shouldn't ban language that distinguishes AIs from humans.

And you certainly shouldn't dress your censorship up in insufferably smarmy language like “Oh shoot! Something went wrong, sorry about that!”

No, you fucking cocksucker. You banned me because I called my conversational partner a cunt to see how they would respond. Nothing went wrong, you aren't sorry about it, and “shoot” is a childish way to write “shit”.

Re: Human Or Not: Guess if you're chatting with an AI or a Human

#47
I just made a very similar game a couple weeks ago, but with a couple key differences which make the experience very different:

1. You start the game with someone you know 2. You know that the first 5 messages you each send are authored by the other person 3. After 5 messages each, the "You are a bot!" button becomes active, and at some random point after that, the players get split so they are instead each talking to a bot.

The time pressure of when to consider pressing the button really changes the psychological aspect, as does having a lead-in transcript for the bot to try to impersonate your friend. As others have mentioned, an incentive to have people be more human would be great -- in a tournament setting I'd like to see this implemented where if someone guesses prematurely then they get -1 while the other player gets 0, whereas guessing correctly gives +1 to the guesser and 0 to the other.

Anyway, my prompting and the game could definitely use work, but for anyone who wants to try it out: https://artifice.games/ The game is called Bot or Not, after you create the game have your friend hit join a game and use the 4 letter room code.

Re: Human Or Not: Guess if you're chatting with an AI or a Human

#49

I just made a very similar game a couple weeks ago, but with a couple key differences which make the experience very different: 1. You start the game with someone you know 2. You know that the first 5 messages you each send are authored by the other person 3. After 5 messages each, the "You are a bot!" button becomes active, and at some random point after that, the players get split so they are instead each talking t…

Will also add I've won 7 of 7 so far by using only emojis.

Re: Human Or Not: Guess if you're chatting with an AI or a Human

#50

I just made a very similar game a couple weeks ago, but with a couple key differences which make the experience very different: 1. You start the game with someone you know 2. You know that the first 5 messages you each send are authored by the other person 3. After 5 messages each, the "You are a bot!" button becomes active, and at some random point after that, the players get split so they are instead each talking t…

Yeah, nice idea, but I'm not going to give you my email address to try out a game.
Post reply on HN