Live data from Hacker News

Canada's population reaches 40M

statcan.gc.ca

41–50 of 116 posts

Re: Canada's population reaches 40M

#41

Congrats, Canada! This has alerted me to the (IMO, pretty surprising) fact that all of Canada holds fewer people than the BosWash corridor.

I'm surprised anyone lives there. I couldn't live that far north.

Mostly kidding but just like land doesn't vote, the size of land doesn't determine how many people live there.

Re: Canada's population reaches 40M

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You just compared apples to oranges. ~6.954 (as of 2016 so actually higher) million of those 15m people live in 8,244 km^2 in the Greater Toronto Hamilton area, which works out to 843 people per square kilometer (vs 3368 for Istanbul). Yes, 1/4 the density, yes, but nowhere close to the bizarre comparison you gave, where you used literally uninhabitable/barely-settled areas of the province (Ontario is huge and mostly…

I might be wrong in the numbers as I just got them from Wikipedia. But to be clear: Istanbul is the name of both the city and the "province" in Turkiye. And I used the larger area number from Wikipedia, which is for the province: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Istanbul So even when using official numbers, the urban density of Istnabul is > 6000 according to Wikipedia. ps: I live in Toronto, so I know Toronto is incomp…

The right comparison would be with the area and population of southern & maybe eastern Ontario and use that. Northern Ontario is really just something else. Anything north of the line where the Canadian shield begins becomes basically unarable and extremely low population density. And once you get past e.g. Timmins, there's really ... "nothing." (Pretty though.)

I don't have the patience to go look this up, but obv it will clearly be below Istanbul, but likely about equivalent with most of the US atlantic region and maybe even parts of the UK etc.

Istanbul/Constantinople, ... a heavily populated city for like 2000 years, not to mention the region going back to the, uh, paleolithic and it's literally basically the origin of ... farming and settled agriculture. Kinda weird comparison.

Re: Canada's population reaches 40M

#44

Congrats, Canada! This has alerted me to the (IMO, pretty surprising) fact that all of Canada holds fewer people than the BosWash corridor.

I'm surprised anyone lives there. I couldn't live that far north. Mostly kidding but just like land doesn't vote, the size of land doesn't determine how many people live there.

Fun fact: the southern-most point in Canada is further south than the northern-most point in Nevada.

Re: Canada's population reaches 40M

#45
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am also amused that Ontario, which is the most populous province has the following statistics: Area: 1,076,395 km square Population: 15.3M Istanbul, which is the biggest city in my home country Turkiye has these: Area: 5,343 (so 200x smaller) Population: 18M (official census is ~16M but even the major cites 18M) I'm not even comparing the much denser places in the world (e.g., Gaza).

Ontario is culturally 2 provinces, southern and northern Ontario. The north is what you normally think of Canada: rocks, trees and lakes. The south is similar to the neighbouring US states of Michigan, Ohio, and New York but with a distinct Canadian identity and a French region in the east. Most of the population (13.4M) lives in the southern part (114,000 km^2)

Still a bit too general.

Southwestern Ontario (Windsor/London) is very culturally and demographically different from Toronto/Golden Horseshoe and Eastern Ontario (Ottawa/Kingston)

Michigan is also culturally different from New York.

Re: Canada's population reaches 40M

#46

Congrats, Canada! This has alerted me to the (IMO, pretty surprising) fact that all of Canada holds fewer people than the BosWash corridor.

I'm surprised anyone lives there. I couldn't live that far north. Mostly kidding but just like land doesn't vote, the size of land doesn't determine how many people live there.

You'd be even more surprised to learn that 50% of Canadians live further south than much of the US ;)

http://i1.wp.com/metrocosm.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/ca...

Re: Canada's population reaches 40M

#47
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am also amused that Ontario, which is the most populous province has the following statistics: Area: 1,076,395 km square Population: 15.3M Istanbul, which is the biggest city in my home country Turkiye has these: Area: 5,343 (so 200x smaller) Population: 18M (official census is ~16M but even the major cites 18M) I'm not even comparing the much denser places in the world (e.g., Gaza).

The provincial area figure is meaningless for computing density. It’s like calculating the density of beer in a glass that’s been poured with 99% head. The real density is in the quarter inch of beer at the bottom of the glass, not the giant blob of foam above it.

Found the Canadian.

Re: Canada's population reaches 40M

#48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Name me a major western metro area with jobs and a good standard of living that doesn't. I remember people banging the drums 10 years agho "come to Berlin, there's so much empty houses". Yeah, that changed quickly.

Chicago

[flagged]

Re: Canada's population reaches 40M

#49

Congrats, Canada! This has alerted me to the (IMO, pretty surprising) fact that all of Canada holds fewer people than the BosWash corridor.

I am also amused that Ontario, which is the most populous province has the following statistics: Area: 1,076,395 km square Population: 15.3M Istanbul, which is the biggest city in my home country Turkiye has these: Area: 5,343 (so 200x smaller) Population: 18M (official census is ~16M but even the major cites 18M) I'm not even comparing the much denser places in the world (e.g., Gaza).

It's worth noting that roughly half of Canada's population lives in the Quebec-Windsor Corridor [0] (the land between Quebec City, QC and Windsor, ON). This region is really the Canadian equivalent of the Boston-Washington corridor in the States, so imagine if nearly 150 million lived in BosWash.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quebec_City%E2%80%93Windsor_Co...

Re: Canada's population reaches 40M

#50
Congratulations Canada - welcome to the big leagues! I hope they continue to grow and become a meaningful player on the global stage!

Canada is a wonderful country with a lot of places to visit, culture to experience, people to interact with - I visited there 5 years ago and was able to visit only a small part of such a beautiful country.

Now, they can (hopefully) deal with the issues that come along with increasing your population by millions per year, along with a lack of economic planning, though from what I hear and read, it seems like not a lot of headway is being made:

- Unaffordable housing to a large portion of Canadians (Condos sell in the more heavily populated parts of Canada for high 6-figures/millions of dollars)

- Unaffordable rent to a large portion of Canadians (A friend in Canada is paying around $1300 CAD a month for a 700sqft bachelor suite not including all utilities)

- Rampant inflation and opportunistic price-gouging from corporations

- The increased load on the already strained healthcare system, making Canadians wait up to 3-4 weeks to see their family doctor, and months/years for specialists.

- Monopolization and lack of competition in critical industries (Telecoms and Grocery come to mind as of late)

- Multiple allegations of Chinese interference in Canadian politics and foreign influence of active MPs that go seemingly ignored by the current party in power.

Post reply on HN