Live data from Hacker News

Who wants to be tracked?

quantable.com

41–50 of 273 posts

Re: Who wants to be tracked?

#41

Better question here is, why is this not handled through the browser instead of relying on individual web apps to do it. Block third party cookies by default, delete other cookies on the last tab or window closed and prompt user to save cookies on a form submit ("do not delete cookies for this domain when leaving" type of prompt, for pages with logins, settings, etc). Also remove features that make easy fingerprintin…

Because the most popular browser is made by an AdTech company

Re: Who wants to be tracked?

#42

Better question here is, why is this not handled through the browser instead of relying on individual web apps to do it. Block third party cookies by default, delete other cookies on the last tab or window closed and prompt user to save cookies on a form submit ("do not delete cookies for this domain when leaving" type of prompt, for pages with logins, settings, etc). Also remove features that make easy fingerprintin…

> Better question here is, why is this not handled through the browser instead of relying on individual web apps to do it.

We had Do-Not-Track header once. Id did not play out very well.

Re: Who wants to be tracked?

#44
post #17
post #6

I don't know how the experience is in US, but in EU it's because GDPR is a complete failure of a law which doesn't actually solve any problem.

What makes you think so? I’ve seen a lot of good come from it.

IMO the only good thing is it made people aware of what's happening with their data online. But then we are still tracked, the web experience is much worse, SMEs got another "screw you" from the regulator by increasing their operating costs to comply with this and big companies who were to blame for this in the first place found ways to bypass it because they have access to strong legal expertise.

Re: Who wants to be tracked?

#46

Better question here is, why is this not handled through the browser instead of relying on individual web apps to do it. Block third party cookies by default, delete other cookies on the last tab or window closed and prompt user to save cookies on a form submit ("do not delete cookies for this domain when leaving" type of prompt, for pages with logins, settings, etc). Also remove features that make easy fingerprintin…

The last thing a browser wants to do is break experience for older sites. If a site relies on 3rd party cookies for log in, it will no longer work on your browser. It makes your browser look shit. Same reason we allow unclosed tags, crossed tags, etc.

Browsers already detect login forms to offer autocompletion and password storage. Surely it wouldn’t be insurmountable to detect cookies being set after a login flow, and let users confirm that they want this login to persist.

Re: Who wants to be tracked?

#47
94% of people want me to be president. Caveat: I did not define what it means for them to want me to be president.

In other words, what does it mean to be "tracked"? How was the question worded? You can change this value from 1% all the way up to 99% depending on how you ask the question, because "being tracked" is open to interpretation.

Truly a useless poll.

Re: Who wants to be tracked?

#48

Better question here is, why is this not handled through the browser instead of relying on individual web apps to do it. Block third party cookies by default, delete other cookies on the last tab or window closed and prompt user to save cookies on a form submit ("do not delete cookies for this domain when leaving" type of prompt, for pages with logins, settings, etc). Also remove features that make easy fingerprintin…

The last thing a browser wants to do is break experience for older sites. If a site relies on 3rd party cookies for log in, it will no longer work on your browser. It makes your browser look shit. Same reason we allow unclosed tags, crossed tags, etc.

We also had shockwave flash, blink tags, keygen tags for cert generation, etc., so yeah, we can change stuff if we need it. But since the biggest browser is owned by an ad company that earns money by tracking us, this will probably never happen.

An alternative would be to have a cookie jar per domain.

Post reply on HN