Live data from Hacker News

Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

theguardian.com

41–50 of 239 posts

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#41

I hope they do a true wireless earbuds set. Those tend to need repairing much more frequently.

They already have those: https://shop.fairphone.com/de/accessories/true-wireless-ster... While I don't see spare parts for those, they claim to be "100% electronic waste neutral". Probably much harder/impossible to repair due to the form factor though, not sure.

They have a 1/10 from iFixit on the repairability score.

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#42
post #30

What are the best noise cancelling headphones to work in cafes? Im using Bose Quiet Comfort II and I always wish they would cancel better.

Noise cancelling only really works for constant sounds (like airplane engines), not for background music/chatter.

The Sony ones worked quite well for that when I tried them. Was genuinely impressed

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Sony XM5's are touted by most reviewers as the best for noise cancelling and calls in noisy environments, although Bose, Apple, Sennheiser etc. are right up there. Each model has it's pros and cons.

I haven't tried XM4's or XM5's but I do have both XM3's and AirPods Max. The XM3's have excellent cancellation and are more comfortable, but have more of a bass-cannon sort of sound profile compared to the AirPods Max, which have cancellation almost as good but have a generally more balanced sound.

I have sony XM3 earbuds and the app has EQ. I assume the XM3 headset app does as well since its the same app.

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#45
post #30

What are the best noise cancelling headphones to work in cafes? Im using Bose Quiet Comfort II and I always wish they would cancel better.

Noise cancelling only really works for constant sounds (like airplane engines), not for background music/chatter.

You're right that it works best for that, but headsets with good noise cancelling tend to have good isolation and the noise cancelling does do some work to suppress other sounds.

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#46

What are the best noise cancelling headphones to work in cafes? Im using Bose Quiet Comfort II and I always wish they would cancel better.

SONY WH-1000XM5 are the best of the bunch, as of now. They offer superlative quality noise cancellation, which I can’t do without.

I have been waiting for Apple to update its AirPods Max before buying them, as I’ve heard much to be admired about them, but no luck yet.

SONY is the one to beat. Expensive, but unrivaled NC and sound fidelity.

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#47
I used to swear by V-Moda for portable headphones. They were highly repairable (you could replace the pads, band, cables, and even the driver if you really wanted). That was, until their Bluetooth enabled line. It had no parts available, and even at that was non trivial to fix with 3rd party parts.

These days, I love my beyerdynamic headphones. I've replaced the drivers, cables, pads, etc over their 10 year life. Only recently have I retired my first pair because of an upgrade. That being said, there's no Bluetooth / wireless, but I'm largely okay with that. If I really needed it, I'd be fine with an external module that hooks up to the cable.

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#48
post #39

Anyone know if these are prone to creaking? I've had to give up on otherwise great headphones because they developed a loud plastic-friction creak which I had no luck repairing. My Sennheiser HD4.50 so far seems immune to that, though has some drawbacks.

What did you try to resolve the issue? I immediately thought lubrication might help. But if the culprit is plastic weakening over time, R.I.P.

I don't remember exactly now, but I seem to remember trying different lubricants and no lubricant, but nothing worked. It was in the plastic-plastic hinges inside the cups.

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They already have those: https://shop.fairphone.com/de/accessories/true-wireless-ster... While I don't see spare parts for those, they claim to be "100% electronic waste neutral". Probably much harder/impossible to repair due to the form factor though, not sure.

They have a 1/10 from iFixit on the repairability score.

Are there wireless eaebuds with a better score? I imagine the form factor is quite limiting.

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#50
I have to ask, as I have never bought active headphones, all my headphones are user servicable already. I've even had to repair the soldering joints on my M40x once. The cables are all removable. The pads are easily replacable.

Are active headphones really that much harder to service? There's no space constraints to warrant glue, clips and ultrasonic welding instead of screws.

Post reply on HN