Live data from Hacker News

Gitlab loses one-third of its value after company issues weak forecast

cnbc.com

41–50 of 220 posts

Re: Gitlab loses one-third of its value after company issues weak forecast

#41
post #21

things like github and gitlab always struck me as oddities. it costs virtually nothing to deploy a containerized gitea and jenkins, or gitlab CE, and you have direct control over its performance and options without any spend. call me old fashioned but these online git-o-matic sites just seem more like rent-seeking during a recession.

I always reference this post when the subject of self-hosting "simple" things comes up: https://utcc.utoronto.ca/~cks/space/blog/sysadmin/RunningSer...

Re: Gitlab loses one-third of its value after company issues weak forecast

#42
in their earnings call @sytses also announced that he has cancer but is powering thru it working full time even while he receives chemotherapy.

snippet: https://twitter.com/OnodaCapital/status/1635379330498060289

wishing him the best of health. he inspires me constantly.

Re: Gitlab loses one-third of its value after company issues weak forecast

#43

As much as I love the product, I've really come to dislike Gitlab as a company. The constant price hikes and the gutting of the free tier aren't exactly developer-friendly.

Same. They forced GitHub to quit resting on their laurels, at least.

Re: Gitlab loses one-third of its value after company issues weak forecast

#44

As much as I love the product, I've really come to dislike Gitlab as a company. The constant price hikes and the gutting of the free tier aren't exactly developer-friendly.

It feels like they've moved into the extract value phase for sure, maybe a bit forced by github actions removing their USP. I'm still using them for now, but I feel the day I move back to Github for the higher profile or self-hosted gitea/forgejo for the data control is coming.

Re: Gitlab loses one-third of its value after company issues weak forecast

#45
post #2

Too many things in Gitlab feel half-baked, like their requirements feature which is essentially just their issue tracker, no document management, just toss some issues in the bin. And they expect enterprises to pay for it because they checked the feature box. https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/project/requirements/

I just think it's too ambitious.

Everything and the kitchen sink just will never be as good as best of breed.

Re: Gitlab loses one-third of its value after company issues weak forecast

#46
I'm annoyed that they don't want my money. I'm a really basic user and try to keep my private and public stuff there instead of GitHub. I fit in a free tier and would happily pay maybe $5 for it. But I wasn't going to spend $20 and definitely won't spend $30.

Come on GitLab, I want to keep using you and see you succeed. Let me pay $5 for some token feature like extra GB of space and to vote with my money to keep you going. I'll even do it for a "supporter" badge on my profile.

Re: Gitlab loses one-third of its value after company issues weak forecast

#47
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This comment strikes me as fundamentally misunderstanding the purpose of GitHub. I don't care that I can set up Gitea (and I already have an instance), I want GitHub because it makes it trivial for people to issue PRs to my code. Then, because everyone has a GitHub account and knows how to use it, and everyone is already on it, everyone else goes on it too. Not to mention that I don't need to maintain CI/container re…

There was an attempt to bring a distributed forge architecture to gitea and co. The idea being the project could be hosted on one instance but you could fork to your own to do your work before PRing back to the project. Github but bring your own. I believe the project died out but it was a good idea. All the benefits of Github without the lock in and single point of failure.

Basically fossil?

Re: Gitlab loses one-third of its value after company issues weak forecast

#48

I'm annoyed that they don't want my money. I'm a really basic user and try to keep my private and public stuff there instead of GitHub. I fit in a free tier and would happily pay maybe $5 for it. But I wasn't going to spend $20 and definitely won't spend $30. Come on GitLab, I want to keep using you and see you succeed. Let me pay $5 for some token feature like extra GB of space and to vote with my money to keep you…

Well, $30 mo is just $1 a day. Depending on where you live it can be nothing.

Re: Gitlab loses one-third of its value after company issues weak forecast

#49
post #21

things like github and gitlab always struck me as oddities. it costs virtually nothing to deploy a containerized gitea and jenkins, or gitlab CE, and you have direct control over its performance and options without any spend. call me old fashioned but these online git-o-matic sites just seem more like rent-seeking during a recession.

There's always opportunity costs. What about regular maintenance and updates? What happens when a bug appears? What if the disk is full?

Working 50% freelance and 50% revenue-generating niche side-project, I always calculate my time costs. Assuming I earn $80 an hour as a freelancer and a hosted git costing $10 a month, if I estimate I will need an additional 15mins a month if I go self-hosted, then I'll pay for the hosted version.

I've seen enough projects, where they decided to self-host gitlab, only to have issues like disk full, updates needed, deployments not initiating.

When suddenly a team of 10 can't push or deploy for a day, there's additional costs there as well.

Re: Gitlab loses one-third of its value after company issues weak forecast

#50
post #12
post #10

What happened to Gitlab? They used to be one step ahead of Github in some areas, then seemed to go full enterprisey and lost their competitive edge. I smell some sales oriented strategies.

When was GitLab ahead of GitHub? I've been using both for as long as I remember, I always thought GitLab is more marketing than GitHub. Believe or not, I prefer BitBucket because I don't care much for CI integrations.

Gitlab CI pipelines are miles ahead from Github Actions or Circle CI.
Post reply on HN