Live data from Hacker News

Udacity and the future of online universities

blogs.reuters.com

41–50 of 73 posts

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#41

I have built something to keep track of all these courses http://www.class-central.com . Currently tracking just Coursera(Stanford's online learning initiative) courses, but would be adding UDACITY and MITx courses(when they are announced) soon.

That looks very useful, thank you! I've signed up for a bunch of these courses, but no emails have come in yet and even the websites themselves aren't very connected, let alone the ones on different frameworks.

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know of at least one Stanford student who feels swindled by this transition to online classes. 1. For some stanford costs a lot of money while online it's free and 2. The time taken developing this class may take away from the in person experience, further reducing the value of attending classes at Stanford. Any idea if these feelings are wide spread? I only have the one sample.

I find this attitude really strange. The value in going to Stanford isn't that you get to take the physical classes, it's that you can walk up to Prof. Ng's office (and/or similar caliber profs) and have a chat, and more importantly target yourself to be doing some research under them before you graduate. Having merely taken a class with someone big in the field (especially a large class) is essentially an interestin…

The online students aren't getting the most valuable part of the entire thing - a diploma with the name "Stanford" on it. Yes computer programming is a young profession that isn't as hidebound as many others, but it is maturing and as is true for most other professions, soon proxies will dominate hiring.

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#43
It all comes down to certifying student proficiency (course credit).

Udacity and Coursera are not really competitors in the area of course content. They are competitors in the area of student certification. In the reputation behind the process. Meaning rigorous final exams, independently administered, suitable for inclusion on curricula vitae, etc.

By offering courses for free, Udacity and Coursera compete directly with Stanford. But Stanford can compete with them just as well, by allowing students to enroll in the free classes, mentoring them, and then offering their own certification exams -- for credit.

My guess is they won't do that. They'll just find someone else to teach the course. But I bet in the future they intend to keep a very close eye on the department.

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#44
Prof. Thrun is an amazing teacher, but I think the 160,000 student sign-ups were due to the Stanford affiliation. Giving up that affiliation will cut enrollement sharply. Any likely business model will cause another sharp decline in enrollment. Thrun has all the right ideas, but on his own it will be tough to execute.

Education is ripe for disruption. Thrun+Ng+Norvig+Stanford as a cohesive team could have made a history altering change in education. It's unfortunate that they aren't a team.

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#45

I have built something to keep track of all these courses http://www.class-central.com . Currently tracking just Coursera(Stanford's online learning initiative) courses, but would be adding UDACITY and MITx courses(when they are announced) soon.

Hi! We built http://www.skillpunch.com about two weeks ago and it looks like we're going into a similar direction. :) Emailed you!

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can confirm that his reasoning is correct. The word on the street is that Sebastian alienated the powers-that-be at Stanford.

I know of at least one Stanford student who feels swindled by this transition to online classes. 1. For some stanford costs a lot of money while online it's free and 2. The time taken developing this class may take away from the in person experience, further reducing the value of attending classes at Stanford. Any idea if these feelings are wide spread? I only have the one sample.

My response to this mentality is the same as when MIT students scoffed at OCW: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2067985.

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#47

I have built something to keep track of all these courses http://www.class-central.com . Currently tracking just Coursera(Stanford's online learning initiative) courses, but would be adding UDACITY and MITx courses(when they are announced) soon.

Thanks for this, keeping track of them all in my Google Calendar was just cluttering it up and hadn't provided any benefit yet. One typo:

Summary of Stanford's online course offerings(not affiliated with Stanford)

should be:

Summary of Stanford's online course offerings (not affiliated with Stanford)

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#48

I have built something to keep track of all these courses http://www.class-central.com . Currently tracking just Coursera(Stanford's online learning initiative) courses, but would be adding UDACITY and MITx courses(when they are announced) soon.

Thanks for this, keeping track of them all in my Google Calendar was just cluttering it up and hadn't provided any benefit yet. One typo: Summary of Stanford's online course offerings(not affiliated with Stanford) should be: Summary of Stanford's online course offerings (not affiliated with Stanford)

Thanks! Updated.

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#49
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> there was this idea of using Aiqus as the discussion forum platform for all the courses Not sure if you're referring to the current bunch of courses or the first three (AI/ML/DB). I'm assuming it's the latter. Aiqus was only used for the AI class. IIRC it was set up independently but someone before the course began and ended up being the pseudo-official Q&A forum (linked to from the main site).

ok, I was not aware that Aiqus was independent of the AI class. Though one of the developers of Aiqus posted in an unofficial FB group of AI class that all the rest of the courses will also use Aiqus during the next session.

Interesting that they seem to have tried to sell Aiqus recently.. https://flippa.com/2673719-q-a-site-on-artificial-intelligen...

Re: Udacity and the future of online universities

#50

I have built something to keep track of all these courses http://www.class-central.com . Currently tracking just Coursera(Stanford's online learning initiative) courses, but would be adding UDACITY and MITx courses(when they are announced) soon.

It would be great if you could provide a RSS feed with course announcements.
Post reply on HN