Live data from Hacker News

Multi-Account Containers

support.mozilla.org

41–50 of 254 posts

Re: Multi-Account Containers

#41

Experience is still lacking compared to Chrome profiles. Chrome profiles are so much better UX wise than any other solution, especially the color coding of the window.

Firefox does profiles too.

But only with command line switches and relaunching, right?

Re: Multi-Account Containers

#42
post #16

I tried to like this the other day but it was a real hassle. I have 3 accounts on a website. I thought I could setup 3 different containers, one for each account. But it turns out that switching between containers is not simple. Whenever I tried to switch, I got a pop up from Firefox asking me if I was really sure I wanted to switch my default container for that website. Sometimes it sent me into a redirect loop with…

Ugh, same. I thought I was the only one that found these to be impossibly buggy. The container setup/management UI is glitchy and it often forgets! containers that were created. It feels like a hack week project that got shipped to production. Despite having containers, Firefox sometimes wants to open the managed website in your current window. Or doesn't ask you at all when you have multiple containers for the same…

The struggle is that the container addon does its own syncing, separate from the browser-wide Firefox account sync (that decides the soon should be installed).

Because syncing is a separate step - yet it still happens concurrently/unpredictably in the background - there is no avoiding the default new user flow that creates 4 default containers at install.

Re: Multi-Account Containers

#44

Experience is still lacking compared to Chrome profiles. Chrome profiles are so much better UX wise than any other solution, especially the color coding of the window.

I'd argue it's far superior - no need to be switching windows constantly and setting the domain automatically loads that site in the correct context.

Re: Multi-Account Containers

#45
post #14

We use different AWS accounts for different purposes at work. It would be an extreme productivity loss if I had to go back to using something other than Firefox's containers.

The Arc browser [1] could be nice alternative as it handles profiles pretty smooth. [1]: https://arc.net/

This smells like pure marketing, incl the company's website. I'd rather use an open-source browser like Firefox.

Re: Multi-Account Containers

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Firefox does profiles too.

But only with command line switches and relaunching, right?

Yes and from within the browser about:profiles

And you can edit the shortcut to ask you which profile you want to use when you start Firefox.

Re: Multi-Account Containers

#49

I've been using this since it was new. I'm very frustrated to say the UI/UX hasn't seen any significant update. Containers are still synced separately, so any fresh install of Firefox will have the tutorial UX and the default 4 containers, even after syncing. Also, address bar completion is still monolithic, making it very easy to accidentally open a site in an undesired container. That can be worked around by adding…

container sync has been a thing for a while, but you have to enable it: https://i.imgur.com/UBj3TjW.png

Re: Multi-Account Containers

#50

I've been using this for a few years now and love it. I wish for two things. 1) i wish there was a way to automatically delete cookies/cache/history from specific containers every time. My personal container needs cookies and logins saved. My other containers don't need persistent cookies. 2) I've always wished for protonvpn to apply to only specific containers. Reading this now though, I see firefox's VPN does that…

What you want is the Temporary Containers addon: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/addon/temporary-con... It will let you open containers that trash cookies on close. You can also set certain URL's to always open in a tmp container which is useful for sites that only let you read x amount of article per month.

How is it different/better from incognito mode ?
Post reply on HN