Live data from Hacker News

Typing “old” (space) into iOS Safari crashes the app

twitter.com

41–50 of 191 posts

Re: Typing “old” (space) into iOS Safari crashes the app

#41
“best “

“bedt “

“old “

“wel “

“dta “

All of these crash safari in iOS for me.

What’s strange about this bug is that it happened overnight for multiple iOS version.

It seems to be a server bug that happens with the requests that populate the suggestions.

Turning off safari suggestions fixes it.

Re: Typing “old” (space) into iOS Safari crashes the app

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're not trolling. I typed it into the search bar. Safari didn't crash. Is the person who wrote the tweet trolling? Probably not either. But what type of iOS device do they have? Which version of iOS are they running? Which language and locale? Those things matter. Other things that apparently shouldn't matter might matter as well: other apps installed or running, notification configuration, how many tabs they hav…

1) It's a tweet, not a bug report. 2) The very first thing any actual engineer on Apple's payroll ought to try to reproduce it will work (most recent official iOS, "happy path" settings that have Safari Suggestions turned on)

1) Yes, people use tweets to report bugs all the time. The problem with nitpicking is that anyone can pick your nits back, which leads me to...

2) Yes, they will, but that won't necessarily repro the bug without knowing which type of device it's running on, so at the very least they might need to check several different devices, and even then other factors can come into play that go beyond basic device configuration.

I'm sure, given that this appears to affect at least a significant minority of users, that Apple will be all over it and will find a way to repro it in relatively short order. Yet, at the same time, it's obscure enough to have escaped their no doubt reasonably robust QA processes before release, so it may well be there are some wrinkles to reproduction that aren't immediately apparent.

Re: Typing “old” (space) into iOS Safari crashes the app

#43
post #22

Can someone contribute more than "lol, me too!" and figure out which API endpoint it's hitting, what it's returning and guess why it's crashing? I don't have an iOS device otherwise I'd do it...

It’s their own “Safari suggestions” service. I don’t know if that’s device local or some Apple API which changed but disabling it prevents the crashes.

I wonder if "Safari Suggestions" is crossing a privacy line with its API it shouldn't and iOS nukes the app from orbit.

Re: Typing “old” (space) into iOS Safari crashes the app

#44
For those not reproducing: your device may have to reside CONUS for some of "tar"(-get), "bes"(-tbuy), "wal"(-mart), "wel"(-ls fargo), "old"(-navy?), "sta"(-rbucks), "pla"(-net fitness?) to work. Try local brands, e.g., "Harrods", "Tesco", "Picard", etc. For my country "Gusto", a casual dining franchise, reproduces the issue. List is from [1].

Edit: stopped reproducing here as of 19:11 UTC.

Edit: some people digged into it[2][3], [2] includes partial endpoint URLs. Apparently this was happening for 7+^H^H 10+ hour.

1: https://www.macrumors.com/2022/11/14/safari-search-crash-bug...

2: https://twitter.com/nejigami/status/1592174411712712706

3: https://twitter.com/take6556/status/1592100775119171584

Re: Typing “old” (space) into iOS Safari crashes the app

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

are you trolling? type it into the search bar and it does crash

They're not trolling. I typed it into the search bar. Safari didn't crash. Is the person who wrote the tweet trolling? Probably not either. But what type of iOS device do they have? Which version of iOS are they running? Which language and locale? Those things matter. Other things that apparently shouldn't matter might matter as well: other apps installed or running, notification configuration, how many tabs they hav…

iPhone 8, iOS 16.1 (20B82) English, US, No Tabs, Wifi

Launch Safari

Tap address bar

Type "old "

Boom!

Re: Typing “old” (space) into iOS Safari crashes the app

#48
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're not trolling. I typed it into the search bar. Safari didn't crash. Is the person who wrote the tweet trolling? Probably not either. But what type of iOS device do they have? Which version of iOS are they running? Which language and locale? Those things matter. Other things that apparently shouldn't matter might matter as well: other apps installed or running, notification configuration, how many tabs they hav…

iPhone 8, iOS 16.1 (20B82) English, US, No Tabs, Wifi Launch Safari Tap address bar Type "old " Boom!

Now we're talking!

Re: Typing “old” (space) into iOS Safari crashes the app

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're not trolling. I typed it into the search bar. Safari didn't crash. Is the person who wrote the tweet trolling? Probably not either. But what type of iOS device do they have? Which version of iOS are they running? Which language and locale? Those things matter. Other things that apparently shouldn't matter might matter as well: other apps installed or running, notification configuration, how many tabs they hav…

iPhone 14, iOS 16.0.3 English, US, No Tabs, Wifi Launch Safari Tap address bar Type "old"

Yes! See, this is what we need more of!
Post reply on HN