Live data from Hacker News

Faux Friendship (2009)

chronicle.com

41–42 of 42 posts

Re: Faux Friendship (2009)

#41

The example in the article about Achilles and Patroclus is not what we would call a "friendship": Achilles was Patroclus' mentor, what means he was his master and had sexual privileges over him. It's not a one-to-one, both-are-equal relationship; it's more similar to a master-slave one. They were sexual partners, not friends ("friend" had different connotations in the classic world).

Yes. I read the article, becoming more sceptical as I went. In my opinion, he underplays modern relationships (relegating them all to Facebook-like) and overplays classical relationships.

It would be good to recognise that he is controversial and is an English Lit professor, not a historian or anthropologist.

Re: Faux Friendship (2009)

#42

Friendship's always struck me as closely tied in with serendipity. When I was in college, I had a wide circle of online friends in the Harry Potter fandom. I figured I'd never meet most of them, many of them were just bored high-schoolers, and a few had pretty serious mental problems. My parents were like "Why do you spend so much time talking to these people?" Hell, when I've mentioned the Harry Potter fandom as a s…

For what it's worth: I didn't mean to sound so dismissive; I was genuinely surprised. Sorry about that.

(This wasn't a thread about fanfic, btw).

Post reply on HN