Live data from Hacker News

One trick Apple uses to make you think green bubbles are “gross”

uxdesign.cc

41–50 of 354 posts

Re: One trick Apple uses to make you think green bubbles are “gross”

#41
post #22

Green was the original color of text messages when the iPhone was introduced. When Apple introduced iMessages four or five years later they made iMessages Blue. This isn’t some great conspiracy.

But the text was black

And the screen had much worse color reproduction, a lower resolution, and much worse text rendering. There are a million reasons to change the color than to make your kids feel bad.

Re: One trick Apple uses to make you think green bubbles are “gross”

#44
This article is weird to me. On one hand, it’s interesting science about color perception. Good stuff.

But on the other hand, it assumes an unsubstantiated motive for why it is as it is. I’ve worked with designers a bunch, and they have all kinds of reasons for why they choose as they do. I would not put this past apple at all. But given there’s no quotes from the original designers, I’d go with “Do no attribute to malice that which you can attribute to incompetence.”

Re: One trick Apple uses to make you think green bubbles are “gross”

#45

When will people realize that the point of differentiating between Android/iOS bubbles isn’t about discriminating against teenagers, but rather it’s about security. If my messages are being sent through an insecure protocol that leaks my messages to the police, carrier, and skids with a rtl-SDR (SMS) rather than a secure encrypted protocol (iMessage), I want it to be obvious. They have every reason to make “green bub…

The point is to make non iPhones uncool.

No, it’s to indicate when you are texting someone over an insecure protocol.

This is just like saying the colored HTTPS symbol in the browser toolbar on websites that support SSL was designed to make websites without SSL look uncool.

Re: One trick Apple uses to make you think green bubbles are “gross”

#46
Might it might it not also be just conditioning? Users have learned to associate green messages with all of the limitations that SMS impose. Hence they perceive it as bad. If that was true, they could’ve picked a higher contrast version instead, and people would still feel the same way.

Re: One trick Apple uses to make you think green bubbles are “gross”

#49

Ye article is complete bullshit and makes-up some fictional examples: for instance the bubbles supposedly on a “brighter screen” are shown as totally desaturated and ‘blown-out’ but unfortunately for the author’s thesis, screen brightness does not affect UI elements in this way, at all. Edit: Haha thx for the downvotes but the article is still lying with phony made-up images.

It does affect your visual impression in the eye, though. If you're using a bright screen in a dim environment, your eyes will be hurt by the bright light, you flinch and that will reduce the perceptive contrast.

Re: One trick Apple uses to make you think green bubbles are “gross”

#50

No one here read the article, it has nothing to do with it being green but with it being low contrast.

To be fair, he could’ve cut to the chase sooner. Since it was a UI UX article, HN readers probably aren’t aware that it’s a contrast between fonts and background, not blue vs green or green vs dark green.
Post reply on HN