Live data from Hacker News

Hackers destroy water pump via SCADA abuse

wired.com

41–42 of 42 posts

Re: Hackers destroy water pump via SCADA abuse

#41

Did anyone else notice this choice comment: “They just figured it’s part of the normal instability of the system,” Weiss told Wired.com. “But it wasn’t until the SCADA system actually turned on and off that they realized something was wrong.” That's a pretty bad sign that the system is so buggy that at first it seems like a hacking attempt is just "normal" instability.

Anybody that's worked with SCADA systems unfortunately wouldn't bat an eye at this. In my own experience they're horribly issue prone, we've churned through 4-5 different vendors in the last 3 years trying to get past basic stability issues.

What issues did you have?

Unfortunately, writing plc code is like writing in assembly with global access to variables. Unless you test things thoroughly it's really tough to have a system run bug free. Thankfully, most of the processes are pretty simple so its not exceedingly hard to test it.

Re: Hackers destroy water pump via SCADA abuse

#42
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So the Blackout was due to a SCADA hack?

The system is redundant, and no single operator should be able to do what was done that day. The military bases went delta-5. Largest military port city, and China's looking to let the fire out of their dragon... Dark days, eh?

Never thought about it that way, but you are right, a system so vital and critical should never be left for 1 human to deal with, reminds me of missile systems where you need 2 keys and Passphrase's, did they ever resolved this? I'm guessing no.
Post reply on HN