Earlier quoted context omitted.
"limited supply" True until another batch of cryptotulip bulbs is released under a new name with slightly different properties and it joins the cryptotulip ecosystem. Any one species of cryptotulip might be a limited supply, but on the whole it's a very inflationary ecosystem, with trust on which is the "true currency" extremely malleable and divided. Even the "original" BitTulip has as many haters expecting its inev…
> How does that consensus happen in a decentralized environment, when clearly it's not happening in this crypto bubble? The earth is a decentralized environment in which USD, EUR, GBP, and JPY float against each other, and their value at any time is determined by market confidence. You shouldn't expect 100% global consensus on a particular cryptocurrency any more than you expect 100% global consensus on (say) USD or…
Back to tulips: though inventing a new tulip does not inflate existing tulips, any level of public support for that tulip dilutes everyone's confidence in the original tulip, and creates two more unstable tulip currencies vs just the one. This is because everyone has just a bit more doubt on which one they should hold.
"But that's decentralized then. If people lose confidence in one of those tulips - good thing you diversified in both.". Sure, except for losing confidence in one is likely to create a cascading effect of lack of confidence in the others as the public starts to rightfully doubt their magical belief that a useless commodity is valuable. Same panics happen with banks. And a big plethora of smaller currencies means the initial dominos of the panic are that much easier to push over - leading to the possibility of the entire market wiping. Tulips all the way down.
Again, not that this isn't the same process found in conventional finance. There's just additional confidence that there will be (perhaps violent) interventions to stem any such lack of confidence/panic before it becomes critical. And there's been a long history of independent currencies being shut down with the same force due to not wanting to compete.