Live data from Hacker News

‘Electric’ chopsticks that make food seem more salty

theguardian.com

41–50 of 139 posts

Re: ‘Electric’ chopsticks that make food seem more salty

#41
I am a Japanese resident. I am not sure how the local people will react to it commercially. So much of the homestyled food goes with traditional cookware. People always are curious to try out things like this - but fall back to age-old practices. I won't be surprised if people continue using their wooden or ceramic chopsticks and this thing becomes a novelty item in upscale department stores.

Consider smoked and deep fried food items. Universally, we have evidence they are connected to cardiovascular diseases and cancers. Or that raw uncooked meat could be risky. Yet, the sashimi, basashi, tempura, and various grilled item food industry is going strong. Educated Japanese understand the risks but it is their way of life - and healthcare has presumably evolved to take care of the sporadic incidents well enough. This country does emphasize on good health and longevity. Such risks from sodium get downplayed easily.

Japan has a high inertia for sometimes good and sometimes not-so-good. But leaving aside this new invention, there is much scope to have even healthier food and lifestyles.

Re: ‘Electric’ chopsticks that make food seem more salty

#43
post #3

Can we be pedantic about the simplistic title? Japan did not invent the chopsticks, but some researchers at a university that were sponsored by a beverage manufacturer did. If these researchers were anywhere else, what would the title read?

If nothing else, this goes to show that headlines are meant only to catch your eye and not be a primary source of info in and of themselves. It's an issue in general, where people think headlines are meant to condense the article as a one-line summary, that's simply not true. I think the use of synecdoche here is reasonable. The publication matters, too. If the researchers were in England, the title would certainly be different. If the researchers were in Brazil, it would likely be similar.

Re: ‘Electric’ chopsticks that make food seem more salty

#44
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The bad thing is that the cultural weight Japan holds is based on myths, hearsay, misunderstandings, or lack of deep insights due to the language barrier. The image of Japan in the US and to a lesser extent in Europe is very far removed from reality.

And everyone else thinks America is what they see on TV. It's not important, unless there are wars about it.

As a Briton, I see an awful lot more of America on TV than Japan. As a result then it's surely inherently more (likely to be) balanced/matching up with reality?

Compared to Japan; the only show I can think of that I've seen that's even sort of set there was The Man in the High Castle!

Re: ‘Electric’ chopsticks that make food seem more salty

#45
post #13
post #3

Can we be pedantic about the simplistic title? Japan did not invent the chopsticks, but some researchers at a university that were sponsored by a beverage manufacturer did. If these researchers were anywhere else, what would the title read?

> Can we pedantic about … I tend to agree. The country in which it was invented, or the nationalities of those who invented it, are not relevant at all. You might include the country if it was newsworthy. Such as new evidence that “The Roman Empire invented the table fork”. I think sub-editors put country descriptors in as mild click bait. Japan is perceived as having an interesting record of niche eye raising invent…

The country in which it was invented is relevant because it was invented to address health concerns caused by the common diet within the country.

Re: ‘Electric’ chopsticks that make food seem more salty

#46
post #3

Can we be pedantic about the simplistic title? Japan did not invent the chopsticks, but some researchers at a university that were sponsored by a beverage manufacturer did. If these researchers were anywhere else, what would the title read?

“Those whacky Japanese” is an anglophone news media trope.

Well, or “inventive” or “futuristic” or “advanced”.

Not all media tropes are negative like I perceive “whacky” to be.

Re: ‘Electric’ chopsticks that make food seem more salty

#49
post #3

Can we be pedantic about the simplistic title? Japan did not invent the chopsticks, but some researchers at a university that were sponsored by a beverage manufacturer did. If these researchers were anywhere else, what would the title read?

Probably "French researchers invent electric chopsticks". The fact we can identify "Japan" as an entity says a lot about the cultural weight it holds. Not a bad thing.

Of course it is a bad thing. It is treated as a homogenous blob, an “other”.
Post reply on HN