Live data from Hacker News

Return to Monkey Island

grumpygamer.com

41–50 of 62 posts

Re: Return to Monkey Island

#41
post #2

An April fools where the Fools is that it was real? This has happened before.

He tweeted in 2013: "If I ever get to make another Monkey Island, I'm going to announce it on April 1st." [1]

Really playing the long game there!

1: https://twitter.com/grumpygamer/status/380819751208902656

Re: Return to Monkey Island

#43
Never got into Monkey Island series. I didn't find the dialogues particularly funny and puzzles were a bit too hard for me to figure out. I wish there was a sequel to Indiana Jones: Fate of Atlantis however. That one I still revisit every few years.

Re: Return to Monkey Island

#44
Funny how this was a April Fools announcement that only fooled people who thought it was fake!

I actually liked Curse of Monkey Island (MI 3) but am very excited for this one.

Also check out the Special Editions for MI 1 and 2 which were very good: https://store.steampowered.com/bundle/6588/Monkey_Island_Col...

Re: Return to Monkey Island

#45
post #44

Funny how this was a April Fools announcement that only fooled people who thought it was fake! I actually liked Curse of Monkey Island (MI 3) but am very excited for this one. Also check out the Special Editions for MI 1 and 2 which were very good: https://store.steampowered.com/bundle/6588/Monkey_Island_Col...

I have no idea why there is so much derision for CoMI on various forums, it was a good game, and the objections to it are never spelled out. Keeping my expectations in check for this new one, too-- why are we assuming it will necessarily be great, again?

Re: Return to Monkey Island

#47

Never got into Monkey Island series. I didn't find the dialogues particularly funny and puzzles were a bit too hard for me to figure out. I wish there was a sequel to Indiana Jones: Fate of Atlantis however. That one I still revisit every few years.

„Fate of Atlantis“ was awesome indeed, especially as it had more earnest overtones closer the end. IIRC contemporary game critics agreed on Indiana Jones being the slightly better game. So I’d love more Indiana Jones adventure games.

However, MI2 is a cult hit, and rightfully so. It was the first adventure game I played on my first PC (a 286 @16 MHz with 2Mb of RAM but upgraded with SB Pro) and still have fond memories of the atmosphere and the excitement when I figured some other puzzle out.

Re: Return to Monkey Island

#48
The Curse of Monkey Island was my first contact with the series and I really enjoyed it at that time! I remember vividly the challenge, as a child, of playing it in English while only having the game’s guide on my native language (Portuguese).

Some parts of the translations where totally messed up, making it so hard to understand what I needed to do in the game that I stopped playing it for some years until I could figure out in English what was been said at some parts of the story.

Finishing it was some kind of a personal achievement for me when I was younger.

Re: Return to Monkey Island

#49
post #45
post #44

Funny how this was a April Fools announcement that only fooled people who thought it was fake! I actually liked Curse of Monkey Island (MI 3) but am very excited for this one. Also check out the Special Editions for MI 1 and 2 which were very good: https://store.steampowered.com/bundle/6588/Monkey_Island_Col...

I have no idea why there is so much derision for CoMI on various forums, it was a good game, and the objections to it are never spelled out. Keeping my expectations in check for this new one, too-- why are we assuming it will necessarily be great, again?

the derision of MI3 stems from the fact that it's not Ron Gilbert "endorsed" (or made from him). My personal opinion is that it's stylistically above everything else but I recently played 3 and 4 again and I have to say: The jokes in 4 are way better. Considering that part 4 is "universally" derided, this just means that it's best to make up your own mind (but for new players who are short on time: just play 1+2 :D).

We assume this one will be great because Ron Gilbert hasn't lost his humor and he recently delivered a good game with Thimbleweed Park. So he's most certainly capable (also other stars like the voice actor of guybrush and the musician Michael Land are back, too).

Re: Return to Monkey Island

#50
post #49
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have no idea why there is so much derision for CoMI on various forums, it was a good game, and the objections to it are never spelled out. Keeping my expectations in check for this new one, too-- why are we assuming it will necessarily be great, again?

the derision of MI3 stems from the fact that it's not Ron Gilbert "endorsed" (or made from him). My personal opinion is that it's stylistically above everything else but I recently played 3 and 4 again and I have to say: The jokes in 4 are way better. Considering that part 4 is "universally" derided, this just means that it's best to make up your own mind (but for new players who are short on time: just play 1+2 :D).…

What's so special about the Ron Gilbert imprimatur? I think the first two games were good, but considering them as "auteur" works is wrong, since so much of what went into them comes from the contributions of many people (the art, small details and minor jokes, etc.). The overall plot and destiny of the characters is totally unimportant, not least because of its status as a farce.
Post reply on HN