Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Have you ever been “poached” internally? Is this even a thing?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 62 posts

Re: Ask HN: Have you ever been “poached” internally? Is this even a thing?

#41
post #35

Your post reads like you think this is scandalous. I’d say it is totally normal in many places even encouraged for people to move between teams and roles in large organizations. What your coworker did was clever in that he demonstrated his skill to the hiring team making it way more likely that they would be open to taking him whether it was he or them that initiated the conversation about moving when the time came.…

> I’d say it is totally normal in many places even encouraged for people to move between teams and roles in large organizations.

My first job out of graduate school, forty years ago, was an office job at a large public university in the U.S. That university announced all nonfaculty job openings through a central office, and current employees were welcome to apply for internal transfers. I was not unhappy in the job I had, but I did interview a couple of times for jobs in other departments that paid a bit better and seemed more interesting. I didn’t get either job, but I came way feeling positive about the process, as I felt that I had been evaluated fairly and that other opportunities would come along eventually. If I hadn’t moved overseas a couple of years later, I might very well have continued working at that university until retirement.

Re: Ask HN: Have you ever been “poached” internally? Is this even a thing?

#44
post #35

Your post reads like you think this is scandalous. I’d say it is totally normal in many places even encouraged for people to move between teams and roles in large organizations. What your coworker did was clever in that he demonstrated his skill to the hiring team making it way more likely that they would be open to taking him whether it was he or them that initiated the conversation about moving when the time came.…

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Have you ever been “poached” internally? Is this even a thing?

#45

My story is a bit different. I started at a company where the engineers hated the customer support team and refused to do any work for them, because they would ask for quite a lot of help. At some point, I finished all of my work early and they kept asking our team for help. I noticed the other teammates wouldn't give them the time day. But, all of their requests ultimately helped our customers which was good for the…

Wow, that's sad. Sometimes I just don't understand, why people (those teams) can not show the respect, that would be due.

Re: Ask HN: Have you ever been “poached” internally? Is this even a thing?

#48
Well, not directly me but indirectly yes. I do a bit of headhunting for friends and family and one of my close relatives is the sales lead in their company's local site. This relative has been trying to land a deal with a customer and needed to hire a person or two to work as subcontractors for this customer.

After a few months of finding no suitable applicants, they asked me for help. I managed to find a few candidates with the very specific skills required for the project and moved forward with one of them.

This company's recruitment is done by another site, not the local one my relative works at and they were so impressed with the prospective hire that they coaxed them to relocate to the city where the other site is located. Basically, the hire got poached as this is work that can't be done remotely and HQ wanted the hire for themselves.

My relative got their recruitment bonus which is approx 1/5th of their monthly salary. The reason I'm a bit miffed is because my relative would've gotten around 2-3 X their monthly salary as bonuses and comission from the deal that they still can't finalize.

Re: Ask HN: Have you ever been “poached” internally? Is this even a thing?

#49
What you described doesn't really sound like poaching, but I think this is normal and it is pretty much how I built my career into the direction I wanted.

When I was a build engineer and wanted to do more tools work, I picked up tool tasks and got put onto the next project as a tools engineer. Later when I grew interested in doing more engine work, I picked up tasks that were related to our central engine tech, worked to minimize divergence, and fixed issues in a way that would get integrated back to the engine. Eventually I officially transferred to the engine team. In my experience "just doing it" is a very effective way to shift into the kinds of roles you're most interested in.

Re: Ask HN: Have you ever been “poached” internally? Is this even a thing?

#50
I lead a team of 7 developers at a ~200 person company. I’ve had several people on other teams ask if they could work on items from our backlog and one eventually transferred to our team full time.

I’ve also had my own directs tell me when they’d rather be working on another team. I’ve always honored these requests and I do everything I can to help them transition.

Early in my career I worked at Microsoft on a product I really wasn’t excited about. I was honest about this with my manager and he introduced me to friends in other orgs which eventually lead to me transferring to one of their teams. To this day I’m grateful for the generosity and want to have the same impact wherever I can.

It’s better for everyone if our primary goal is to make each other happy rather than extract as much “value” as possible from someone for our own benefit.

Post reply on HN