Live data from Hacker News

My Personal Note Taking Journey

phonetonote.com

41–50 of 89 posts

Re: My Personal Note Taking Journey

#41
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> You can easily set up sync using SyncThing Unless you're on iOS/iPadOS, as far as I know.

You can use iCloud to sync everything - your actual notes and the workspace files. Easy, free, works great.

Assuming all the devices you work on are Apple devices.

Some people use iPhones but work on Windows/Linux.

Re: My Personal Note Taking Journey

#42
This year I'm just trying a paper agenda. Pretty standard small agenda I think. Each page view is a week: on the left page a detailed view of the week with space for each day, on the right a freeform text area to jot down unstructured ideas/goals for the week.

I find this approach quite similar to TeuxDeux in the OP.

Re: My Personal Note Taking Journey

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can use iCloud to sync everything - your actual notes and the workspace files. Easy, free, works great.

Assuming all the devices you work on are Apple devices. Some people use iPhones but work on Windows/Linux.

If you choose to straddle ecosystems there really isn't that much that the likes of Obsidian can do to help though (especially when it comes to iPhone). I use Obsidian with Mac + Android (Synced via Dropbox, and backed up using git) and it works. Little bit of manual setup, but I can handle that.

At the end of the day Obsidian is just a directory structure of Markdown files. If needed, you can edit them with Obsidian (say using the Dropbox app).

Re: My Personal Note Taking Journey

#44

Is it just me, but using local files just gives me an uneasy feeling when it comes to robust backups. How do I make sure my local files are backed up somewhere? What happens when I want to revert? How do I really know I didn't accidentally just wipe out all my notes locally with a bad command. How do I 100% know that changes I made on my desktop are reflected on other devices? The obvious solution is to keep files in…

Obsidian has a git plugin that I've been using for a while. It's pretty configurable for frequency of commits, and I've never had a problem with it.

It is at the end of the day a directory of Markdown files, so it's flexible with other tools. I have a bunch of things like Markdownload configured to write into various sub-directories.

Re: My Personal Note Taking Journey

#45
post #23
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not parent, but ... > I see this comment or some variation of it every time a new product is shared here that has such a model. I observe something similar, but we seem to have drawn different conclusions. > What I rarely if ever see is a proposal for how the developer should make money instead of a subscription. At the risk of sounding trite, I think people who find subscriptions unpalatable would be happy with anyt…

I think a one time payment is great when you’re selling a standalone app, but for online services, I don’t think there are many options beyond a subscription or possibly some kind of pay-as-you-go model, the latter of which has a whole host of other issues. I don’t think it’s invalid to express fatigue at the model, but as feedback on a specific app/service here, it’s a bit tired without at least some kind of suggest…

One-time payments for Apps are a lie we tell ourselves anyway. There will always be another version, and the new version with have that feature we need (or support for new hardware).

Like you, I find the attitude about subscriptions frustrating. "Wants to be paid but doesn't want to pay". And yes, it's possible that the person objecting lives outside capitalist society and contributes an enormous volume to open source (or other volunteering), but statistically less likely.

I can see the benefit of bundling (e.g. Setapp), so that you're not killed by a million tiny subscriptions, but people need to be paid for their work, so one way or another money needs to flow to the creator.

Re: My Personal Note Taking Journey

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People seem to prefer subscriptions to expensive one-time purchases... What's a developer to do?

That does not seem to be the case, at all. For example, people complained very loudly about not being able to buy photoshop anymore. Any time office365 is discussed, again people complain. People seem to hate subscriptions. What is true instead is that people are forced into subscriptions because one-time purchases are just not offered anymore.

As I mentioned on a thread, one-time purchases are a lie we tell ourselves anyway, and every version of Office or Photoshop (pre subscription). You still have to pay for the newest version with the support for new hardware/OS and features.

Re: My Personal Note Taking Journey

#47
After having tried a number of approaches, including various VIM plugins, I decided to go with the Apple Notes. If you are bought into Apples ecosystem, it works incredibly well. Syncs to cloud. Available on both my desktop and phone. I recently went through a prep phase, which required tons of note taking with screenshots, pictures etc. it scaled beautifully.

Re: My Personal Note Taking Journey

#48
post #17

I am a Logseq user. One thing I realised is that PKM people tend to spend 99% of intellectualising and fetishising different systems like Zettlekasten and P.A.R.A. when in the end your output is what matters. I wasted months, just to realise the tools or systems do not matter at all. Interlinking notes doesn't scientifically make you a better writer, writing does.

I think apart from just writing, the one thing that feels like it matters to me is rewriting and consolidation. Having years of notes you never revisit does very little. What is good about some of the systems is that they provide a framework for consolidation and forcing you to keep reviewing things. But I find the specifics of how you end up reviewing and consolidating changes very little, as long as you do.

If anything, I think re-writing works better than interlinking notes, because it forces you to consider the whole. But at some point some things becomes static enough that putting it aside and linking to it may be worthwhile.

Re: My Personal Note Taking Journey

#49

Is it just me, but using local files just gives me an uneasy feeling when it comes to robust backups. How do I make sure my local files are backed up somewhere? What happens when I want to revert? How do I really know I didn't accidentally just wipe out all my notes locally with a bad command. How do I 100% know that changes I made on my desktop are reflected on other devices? The obvious solution is to keep files in…

Have you considered TiddlyWiki running on NodeJS? It seems to tick most of your requirements.

Re: My Personal Note Taking Journey

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What? Where's the evidence? My 0.02: people feel the exact opposite. People hate subscriptions, people hate not having control over something that they feel has been "purchased".

The evidence is all the companies moving to subscriptions and not back. It’s searching app stores and seeing all the non subscription prices being <$20.

That's poor evidence, considering some of the first movers to this new model were people who ensured their services were going to be used irrespective of what their pricing model was, and then everyone else following without providing an alternative. Where's a consumer to go?
Post reply on HN