Live data from Hacker News

Unvaccinated workers who lose jobs ineligible for unemployment benefits (Canada)

edmontonjournal.com

41–50 of 600 posts

Re: Unvaccinated workers who lose jobs ineligible for unemployment benefits (Canada)

#41
post #8

> The department said if an employee doesn’t report to work or is suspended or terminated for refusing to comply with a vaccine mandate, the employer should indicate that they quit, took a leave of absence or were dismissed – potentially disqualifying them from collecting EI. Why isn't this fraud?

Why would it be?

Re: Unvaccinated workers who lose jobs ineligible for unemployment benefits (Canada)

#42
This is complete BS and I say that as a vaccinated health care worker. They are now considering putting sick but vaccinated workers back to work instead of not sick but unvaccinated. How can they justify that? It seems pretty obvious they are not worried about public health but rather some sort of control over people. Do as we say or you will be punished. I am feeling disgraced as a Canadian. And am sorry for my fellow workers who choose not to get vaccinated and lost their jobs.

Re: Unvaccinated workers who lose jobs ineligible for unemployment benefits (Canada)

#43
post #2

I don't understand, if the vaccines work then why the issue? However the vaccines don't stop you catching or spreading the virus, so why is this banning of the unvaccinated a thing? Very odd.

Your problem seems to be that you don't understand the concept of probabilities. Something can work 80-90% of the time, but not 100%.

Re: Unvaccinated workers who lose jobs ineligible for unemployment benefits (Canada)

#44
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> However the vaccines don't stop you catching or spreading the virus Vaccines reduce spread. Even if it doesn’t stop spread completely it’s still a significant factor.

It is fairly clear that is it not a significant factor, even before omicron. I don't know how these claims that lack a solid scientific basis still continue. You cannot attribute a capability to a vaccine that has not been confirmed through high quality evidence.

https://khub.net/documents/135939561/390853656/Impact+of+vac...

There are a number of studies both identifying a mechanism for covid to have reduced spread due to vaccine and verifying that this occurs empirically. The difference is decreased with newer variants but:

1. Hybrid immunity is even stronger at reducing spread and only possible with prior vaccination

2. There is still non-negligible reduced spread which can be impactful.

Re: Unvaccinated workers who lose jobs ineligible for unemployment benefits (Canada)

#45
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If a seatbelt doest stop you from dying in 100% of car crashes, I don't understand why they're mandatory?

Do we ban people from driving if they refuse to wear seatbelts?

You get a ticket, and too many of those tickets and you lose your license, so yes.

Re: Unvaccinated workers who lose jobs ineligible for unemployment benefits (Canada)

#46
post #2

I don't understand, if the vaccines work then why the issue? However the vaccines don't stop you catching or spreading the virus, so why is this banning of the unvaccinated a thing? Very odd.

My understanding is that the vaccines aren’t completely effective at stopping you catching/spreading, but they are a whole lot better than being immune naive altogether. Casual googling has given me some Washington state pdf data that says even in the most robust cohort (13-29 year olds) unvaccinated folks get Covid at 3x the rate of unvaccinated and the differences only get more dramatic from there. If you have more…

There’s an Antarctic research station of entirely triple vaxxed people that is on complete lockdown now because most of them have Covid. I know 22 people who have gotten positive tests in the last two weeks, all vaccinated. Sports leagues practically 100% vaccinated and dozens and dozens and dozens of players out for Covid. I do not believe for one second any public health data today claiming only 1/5 new cases are vaccinated.

Re: Unvaccinated workers who lose jobs ineligible for unemployment benefits (Canada)

#47
post #2

I don't understand, if the vaccines work then why the issue? However the vaccines don't stop you catching or spreading the virus, so why is this banning of the unvaccinated a thing? Very odd.

My understanding is that it’s either, control, money or both. It is not logical public health policy so greed and tyranny are the other possible explanations.

it’s not logical health policy to enforce a mandate that reduces hospitalization rate? is today opposite day or something?

Re: Unvaccinated workers who lose jobs ineligible for unemployment benefits (Canada)

#48
post #2

I don't understand, if the vaccines work then why the issue? However the vaccines don't stop you catching or spreading the virus, so why is this banning of the unvaccinated a thing? Very odd.

Brakes on your vehicle don't stop you either. They just slow you down, hopefully when you want... but not always.

Re: Unvaccinated workers who lose jobs ineligible for unemployment benefits (Canada)

#49
post #6
post #2

I don't understand, if the vaccines work then why the issue? However the vaccines don't stop you catching or spreading the virus, so why is this banning of the unvaccinated a thing? Very odd.

If a seatbelt doest stop you from dying in 100% of car crashes, I don't understand why they're mandatory?

Whatever one thinks about seatbelts and the ethics of seatbelt laws, they’re a horrendously bad analogy for “vaccines”. A seatbelt can always be removed after use. A “vaccine” cannot. If somebody is concerned about potential issues with the “vaccine” comparing it to a seatbelt feels disingenuous because the “vaccine” can never be undone.

Re: Unvaccinated workers who lose jobs ineligible for unemployment benefits (Canada)

#50
To clarify for non-Canadians:

EI benefits are generally only given if you lose your employment through no fault of your own (didn't quit or get fired). What this policy does is clarify that losing work hours or your job due to vaccine refusal after a workplace vaccination mandate (outside of medical exemptions) does NOT count as "through no fault of your own", and instructs employers to indicate as such.

So: For the duration of the pandemic, if your workplace mandates COVID vaccination and you refuse and then get fired over it, you're not eligible for EI any more than you would be if you got fired for cause.

Post reply on HN